Season 4 Discussion

SquiddlyPie

random gal


1,199 posts
$549 doubloons
So till now Season 1 has 0 bad episodes, Season 2 has 2 bad and 1 really bad and Season 3 has 3 bad IMO, let's see how bad is Season 4...because many say that this season is weaker than the first 3...(My personal favourite is still season 3 even though season 1 hasn't got any bad episode)
-Amazing (episodes I love/or really really like)
-Good (episodes I really like/or generally like)
-Meh (episodes I think are so so or even like a lil bit)
-Bad (episodes I don't like/hate)



Fear of a Krabby Patty - Amazing
Shell of a Man - Amazing
The Lost Mattress - Amazing
Krabs vs Plankton - Good
Have You Seen This Snail - Amazing (one of my favourites of this season and that's why it is highlighted)
Skill Crane - Amazing (also one of my favourites)
Good Neighbours - Good (I enjoyed it...)
Selling Out - Good
Funny Pants - Meh (I really wanted to give it a ''good'' sign , but it didn't really work out for me as an episode)
Dunces and Dragons - Amazing (one of my favs as well, the special episodes of season 4 were GREAT)
Enemy In Law - Good
MM/BB VI - Good
Patrick Smartpants - Amazing
Squidbob Tentaclepants - Good (close to meh, but made it in with 7/10)
Krusty Towers - Amazing (and also the only episode I have watched 4-5 times IN A ROW ;) it's definitely a gem)
Mrs Puff You're Fired - Good (close to amazing)
Chimps Ahoy - Good
Ghost Host - Good
Whale of a Birthday - Amazing (love it as well)
Karate Island - Good
All That Glitters - Bad
Wishing You Well - Amazing (love it!!! )
New Leaf - Amazing (Loved it, apart from the ending which was meh but didn't really disturb me since the first 9 1/2 were brilliant)
Once Bitten - Amazing (Episode 73 was a really good pairing for me , I love this episode too)
Bummer Vacation - Good
Wigstruck - Meh (this one was close to bad though)
Squidtastic Voyage - Amazing
That's No Lady - Amazing
The Thing - Amazing (if you are surprised why I gave this ''amazing'' , go to this episode's topic thread , I've explained them all in there..)
Hocus Pocus - Good
Driven To Tears - Good
Rule of Dumb - Good
Born To Be Wild - Good
Best Frenemies - Amazing
The Pink Purloiner - Amazing (love it)
Squid Wood - Bad (I really dislike this episode, this is really really bad, I am so angry everytime I watch this episode)
Best Day Ever - Amazing
The Gift of Gum - Good
Definitely a good season

Season 1 : 0 Bad
Season 2 : 3 Bad
Season 3 : 3 Bad
Season 4 : 2 Bad :p (so I guess this season worked well for me...)
 

Jack M Crazyfish

I'm back, I guess.


878 posts
$639 doubloons
And this way.

Best: Skill Crane
Runners Up: Wishing You Well, Krusty Towers and Dunces and Dragons
Worst: All That Glitters
Runners Up: Whale of a Birthday, Squid Wood and Good Neighbors
Guilty Pleasure: The Gift of Gum
Underrated Gems: Bummer Vacation, The Gift of Gum, Best Frenemies and Mrs. Puff You're Fired
Overrated: Driven to Tears, MM/BB VI: The Motion Picture
Overhated: The Gift of Gum, The Thing, Wigstruck, Karate Island
Most Forgettable: That's No Lady, Selling Out and Born to be Wild
 

pgh214

New Member


93 posts
$111 doubloons
No doubt the toughest season to review. It had A LOT of ups and downs. Thousands of fans think that this marked the downturn of spongebob. I wouldn't exactly agree with that. I actually found season 4 to be a solid season. Its not season 1. Its not season 2 or 3. It's kind of its own, new thing. In many ways it didnt feel like the same spongebob from 2004. So I would rather break up the series into "Spongebob I" and "Spongebob II". Because think about it. So much more potty humor. So much faster paced. So much more complex storylines. Spongebob is now a plain dork who laughs and annoys, but can be himself at times. Patrick is actually very entertaining, but not quite the misleading wise guy he was before. Squidward wants to kill himself every episode. Sandy is now completely and utterly absorbed in science and literally nothing else. Krabs takes over as the show's villain. Plankton gets a little more fun with his formula schemes, i admit. 81/100

Fear of a Krabby Patty - 9.0
Shell of a Man - 7.2
The Lost Mattress - 8.9
Krabs vs. Plankton - 9.0
Have You Seen This Snail - 9.0
Skill Crane - 8.8
Good Neighbors- 7.8
Selling Out - 8.0
Funny Pants - 7.7
Dunces and Dragons - 9.3
Enemy In-Law - 7.7
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - 9.2
Patrick SmartPants - 7.4
SquidBob TentaclePants - 7.4
Krusty Towers - 9.8
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - 9.1
Chimps Ahoy - 7.5
Ghost Host - 6.2
Whale of a Birthday - 7.9
Karate island - 8.5
All That Glitters - 6
Wishing You Well - 8.2
New Leaf - 8.8
Once Bitten - 8.2
Bummer Vacation - 8.4
Wigstruck - 7.6
Squidtastic Voyage - 9.8
That's No Lady - 8.3
The Thing - 8.6
Hocus Pocus - 8.9
Driven To Tears - 9.2
Rule of Dumb - 8.7
Born to be Wild - 8.1
Best Frenemies - 8.5
The Pink Purloiner - 9.0
Squid Wood - 6.0
Best Day Ever - 9.0
The Gift of Gum - 9.1
 

Amphitrite

LBW Zelda


4,995 posts
$6,137 doubloons
Ratings:

Amazing: 10
Great: 9
Good: 8
Average: 6-7
Mediocre: 4-5
Bad: 2-3
Awful: 0-1

Fear of a Krabby Patty - Amazing
Shell of a Man - Amazing
The Lost Mattress - Amazing
Krabs vs. Plankton - Good
Have You Seen This Snail? - Amazing
Skill Crane - Amazing
Good Neighbors - Mediocre
Selling Out - Great
Funny Pants - Bad
Dunces and Dragons - Amazing
Enemy In-Law - Average
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - Great
Patrick SmartPants - Amazing
SquidBob TentaclePants - Average
Krusty Towers - Amazing
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - Amazing
Chimps Ahoy - Good
Ghost Host - Good
Whale of a Birthday - Good
Karate Island - Good
All That Glitters - Awful
Wishing You Well - Amazing
New Leaf - Bad
Once Bitten - Good
Bummer Vacation - Great
Wigstruck - Bad
Squidtastic Voyage - Average
That's No Lady - Great
The Thing - Awful
Hocus Pocus - Good
Driven to Tears - Bad
Rule of Dumb - Great
Born to Be Wild - Average
Best Frenemies - Good
The Pink Purloiner - Great
Squid Wood - Awful
Best Day Ever - Mediocre
The Gift of Gum - Good

Overall: Good season

Favorite episode: Dunces and Dragons

Least favorite episode: The Thing
 

Ihavedahswag

Take it to the Top!


1,542 posts
$661 doubloons
Ranked out of 5

5 - 8 Episodes
4 - 13 Episodes
3 - 11 Episodes
2 - 6 Episodes
1 - 0 Episodes

Fear of a Krabby Patty - 5
Shell of a Man - 4
The Lost Mattress - 5
Krabs vs. Plankton - 5
Have You Seen This Snail? - 5
Skill Crane - 5
Good Neighbors - 4
Selling Out - 3
Funny Pants - 3
Dunces and Dragons - 4
Enemy In-Law - 3
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - 4
Patrick SmartPants - 5
SquidBob TentaclePants - 4
Krusty Towers - 5
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - 4
Chimps Ahoy - 3
Ghost Host - 2
Whale of a Birthday - 3
Karate Island - 2
All That Glitters - 2
Wishing You Well - 5
New Leaf - 4
Once Bitten - 4
Bummer Vacation - 4
Wigstruck - 4
Squidtastic Voyage - 3
That's No Lady - 4
The Thing - 4
Hocus Pocus - 4
Driven to Tears - 2
Rule of Dumb - 2
Born to Be Wild - 3
Best Frenemies - 3
The Pink Purloiner - 3
Squid Wood - 3
Best Day Ever - 3
The Gift of Gum - 2
 

BenPaz: Act Zero

My Waifu


2,792 posts
$1,324 doubloons
I FINISHED THE SEASON 4 RE-WATCH!
Now it's Ranking Time!
Ratings are Good, Okay, and BAD

Fear of a Krabby Patty- Good
Shell of a Man- Good
The Lost Mattress- Good
Krabs vs Plankton- Good
Have You Seen This Snail- Okay
Skill Crane- Good
Good Neighbors- BAD
Selling Out- Good
Funny Pants- Okay
Dunces and Dragons- Good (kind of overrated though)
Enemy In-Law- Good
MM&BB VI- Good
Patrick Smartpants- Okay
Krusty Towers- Good
Mrs. Puff You're Fired- Good
Chimps Ahoy- Okay
Ghost Host- Good
Whale of a Birthday- Good
Karate Island- Good
All That Glitters- BAD
Wishing You Well- Good
New Leaf- Good
Once Bitten- Okay
Bummer Vacation- Okay
Wigstruck- BAD
Squidtastic Voyage- Okay
That's No Lady- Good
The Thing- Good
Hocus Pocus- Good
Driven to Tears- Okay
Rule of Dumb- BAD
Born To Be Wild- Good
Best Frenemies- Good
Pink Purloiner- Okay
Squid Wood- Good
Best Day Ever- BAD
Gift of Gum- Okay

22 Good
10 Okay
5 BAD

I guess it's an OKAY season. I remembered it being a lot better. I mean the episodes that are Art and Good are usually really good. But some of the okay stuff pulls the season a little bit down. I mean 7 bad episodes is a lot. 9 okay episodes isn't that great either.

Also my Top 5 of the Season

5. Born to be Wild
4. Krabs vs. Plankton
3. Shell of a Man
2. Skill Crane
1. Wishing You Well

Bottom 5

5. Rule of Dumb
4. Best Day Ever
3. Good Neighbors
2. Wigstruck
1. All That Glitters

That's it. I'm currently on S3 now. To be continued...
 

pgh214

New Member


93 posts
$111 doubloons
I recently got the DVD so I get to see all 38 segments. And let me say, these episodes are SO GOOD so far. The story elements are actually better than season 3. However, the humor is a bit less slapstick and there are more depression based episodes. But really, as someone who normally drew the line at season 3, I was wrong about season 4. Its good! (Take out Ghost Host and Squid Wood though, heh)
 

NerdyKairi

My Photo is a Mood


1,247 posts
$1,344 doubloons
I love season 4 mostly for the specials minus Once Bitten, it must me the only episode I don´t enjoy that much except for the ending.
 

Greek Chorus

Oh, grock.


578 posts
$1,560 doubloons
Currently in the process of rewatching this season, and I must say, it's better than I was expecting. Currently it's kinda on the cusp between being "Meh" and "Good." I'll say that 26 Good episodes will guarantee a good rating for this season, currently I'm at 22 good episodes, four meh episodes, and two bad episodes with 10 episodes left to burn through. Don't quite have a bottom 5 yet, but I can at least offer a top 5.

TOP FIVE:
5.) "Krusty Towers"
4.) "Dunces and Dragons"
3.) "Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture"
2.) "Born to Be Wild"
1.) "Fear of a Krabby Patty"

Also, as a side-note, while I was expecting to dislike "A Whale of a Birthday..." it wasn't that bad. It was only a 5/10, but that still means it's just okay. I don't think it should be anywhere near as infamous as it is.
 

CakeCup

Facing the BSOD


5,877 posts
$11,879 doubloons
Now in Rating Rainbow form:
1. Have you seen this Snail? (A++)
2. Krusty Towers (A+)
3. Dunces and Dragons (A+)
4. Fear of a Krabby Patty (A+)
5. Wishing you Well (A+)
6. Patrick Smartpants and Skill Crane (A+)
7. MM/BB VI: The Motion Picture and Mrs. Puff, You're Fired (A)
8. Shell of a Man (A)
9. The Lost Mattress (A-)
10. Best Frenemies (A-)
11. The Pink Purloiner (A-)
12. Selling Out (A-)
13. That's No Lady (B+)
14. New Leaf (B+) tied with Squid Wood (B+), yeah, I like the episode.
15. Once Bitten (B+)
16. Rule of Dumb (B+), deal with it.
17. Whale of a Birthday (B+)
18. Bummer Vacation (B) tied with Enemy In-Law (B)
19. SquidBob TentaclePants (B), would have been higher but the ending ruined it for me.
20. Driven to Tears (B)
21. Krabs vs. Plankton (B)
22. Squidtastic Voyage (B)
23. Karate Island (B)
24. Chimps Ahoy tied with Ghost Host (both B)
25. Born to be Wild (B)
26. Hocus Pocus (B-)
27. Best Day ever (B-)
28. The Thing (C)
29. The Gift of Gum (C-)
30. Funny Pants (C-) tied with Wigstruck (C-)
31. Good Neighbors (D+)
32. All that Glitters (F)
 

DigDugtrio

New Member


149 posts
$308 doubloons
Fear of a Krabby Patty- Great
Shell of a Man- Good
The Lost Mattress- Great
Krabs vs Plankton- Good
Have You Seen This Snail- Good
Skill Crane- Great
Good Neighbors- Meh
Selling Out- Good
Funny Pants- Meh
Dunces and Dragons- Good
Enemy In-Law- Good
MM&BB VI- Great
Patrick Smartpants- Good
Krusty Towers- Great
Mrs. Puff You're Fired- Great
Chimps Ahoy- Good
Ghost Host- Good
Whale of a Birthday- Good
Karate Island- Good
All That Glitters- Bad
Wishing You Well- Good
New Leaf- Good
Once Bitten- Good
Bummer Vacation- Good
Wigstruck- Bad
Squidtastic Voyage- Good
That's No Lady- Good
The Thing- Bad
Hocus Pocus- Good
Driven to Tears- Great
Rule of Dumb- Awful
Born To Be Wild- Good
Best Frenemies- Great
Pink Purloiner- Great
Squid Wood- Meh
Best Day Ever- Meh
Gift of Gum- Meh

Great: 7
Good: 19
Meh: 5
Bad: 3
Awful: 1


Good season :sbthumbs:
 

IAmAGoofyGoober2004

see ya


1,525 posts
$2,097 doubloons
61a. B+
61b. A
62a. A+
62b. A+
63. A+
64a. A-
64b. C+
65a. A+
65b. B
66. A+
67a. A
67b. A
68a. A+
68b. B
69a. A+
69b. A
70a. A-
70b. D+
71a. A+
71b. A
72a. B-
72b. A+
73a. A-
73b. A+
74a. A+
74b. B-
75a. A-
75b. A
76a. A+
76b. C+
77a. A-
77b. A
78a. A+
78b. A-
79a. B
79b. B-
80a. A+
80b. A-

Overall, this season has had a few more let-downs of segments/episodes, yet spot-on with jokes/gags! Excellent and beautiful visuals and experimental with plots/concepts, though later Season 4 was weaker and not as good than early to mid Season 4: which brings Season 4's final ranking to... 10/10 (A+)! It is now ranked Number 1 (No. 1) in my top seasons of SpongeBob SquarePants!
 

WhosTheRealPinheadPatrick?

New Member


163 posts
$390 doubloons
Ratings: Gold, Good, Average, Meh, Bad, Abysmal, ScuMbob

Fear of A Krabby Patty - Good
Shell of A Man - Good
The Lost Matress - Good
Krabs vs Plankton - Good
Have You Seen This Snail? - Gold
Skill Crane - Good
Good Neighbors - ScuMbob
Selling Out - Good
Funny Pants - ScuMbob
Dunces And Dragons - Gold
Enemy In-Law - Average
Mermaidman And Barnacleboy VI: The Motion Picture - Good
Patrick SmartPants - Gold
SquidBob TentaclePants - Good
Krusty Towers - Gold
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - Meh
Chimps Ahoy - Good
Ghost Host - Good
Whale Of A Birthday - Average
Karate Island - Good
All That Glitters - Bad
Wishing You Well - Good
New Leaf - Good
Once Bitten - Good
Bummer Vacation - Gold
Wigstruck - Average
Squidtastic Voyage - Good
That's No Lady - Good
The Thing - ScuMbob
Hocus Pocus - Gold
Driven to Tears - Gold
Rule of Dumb - Good
Born To Be Wild - ⅁ood
Best Frenemies - Gold
The Pink Purloiner - Gold
Squid Wood - Squid Woodn't watch this episode, cause it's BAD!
Best Day Ever =) Good =)
The Gift Of Gum - Average

Top Five:
5. Driven To Tears, drove me to tears in a good way.
4. Dunces And Dragons wasn't like a dunce, it was like an awesome dragon.
3. The Pink Purloiner was funny, and was sort of emotional near the end.
2. Hocus Pocus was a magically funny, and underrated, episode.
1. Have You Seen This Snail? More like, How Haven't You Seen This Amazing Episode?

Bottom Five:
5. Squid Wood woodn't make me laugh at Mini-Squidward.
4. All That Glitters is not this episode.
3. Funny Pants isn't funny, and belongs in a pair of p- you know what I mean.
2. Good Neighbors isn't good, and if it were a person, I wouldn't be it's neighbor.
1. The Thing. ::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise::::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise:: ::dolphin noise::::dolphin noise:: and ::dolphin noise:: Is what I think of this horrible.. thing.
 

Greek Chorus

Oh, grock.


578 posts
$1,560 doubloons
Gonna go ahead and do my usual rating scale now that I've rewatched the Season.
  • 0/10 - Unforgivable
  • 1/10 - Atrocious
  • 2/10 - Terrible
  • 3/10 - Bad
  • 4/10 - Mediocre
  • 5/10 - Meh
  • 6/10 - Okay
  • 7/10 - Good
  • 8/10 - Great
  • 9/10 - Amazing
  • 10/10 - Perfect
On to the list!
  • Fear of a Krabby Patty - Perfect
  • Shell of a Man - Great
  • The Lost Mattress - Great
  • Krabs vs. Plankton - Great
  • Have You Seen This Snail? - Good
  • Skill Crane - Amazing
  • Good Neighbors - Terrible
  • Selling Out - Okay
  • Funny Pants - Mediocre
  • Dunces and Dragons - Amazing
  • Enemy In-Law - Okay
  • Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - Amazing
  • Patrick SmartPants - Great
  • SquidBob TentaclePants - Great
  • Krusty Towers - Amazing
  • Mrs. Puff You're Fired - Great
  • Chimps Ahoy - Good
  • Ghost Host - Great
  • Whale of a Birthday - Meh
  • Karate Island - Great
  • All That Glitters - Bad
  • Wishing You Well - Great
  • New Leaf - Okay
  • Once Bitten - Great
  • Bummer Vacation - Good
  • Wigstruck - Bad
  • Squidtastic Voyage - Good
  • That's No Lady - Okay
  • The Thing - Terrible
  • Hocus Pocus - Good
  • Driven To Tears - Good
  • Rule of Dumb - Great
  • Born to Be Wild - Amazing
  • Best Frenemies - Great
  • The Pink Purloiner - Great
  • Squid Wood - Bad
  • Best Day Ever - Meh
  • The Gift of Gum - Good
(yay i included colors this time)

  • 2 Terrible episodes
  • 3 Bad episodes
  • 1 Mediocre episode
  • 2 Meh episodes
  • 4 Okay episodes
  • 7 Good episodes
  • 13 Great episodes
  • 5 Amazing episodes
  • 1 Perfect episode
Which in simpler terms means...
  • 26 episodes considered "Good"
  • 7 episodes considered "Meh"
  • 5 episodes considered "Bad"
There is pretty much no denying Season 4 isn't as solid as the show's first three seasons. However, as a whole, I'd say that I still, for the most part, do enjoy Season 4. The bad episodes are... much more plentiful, sure, but with well over half the season being good, I think that watching through Season 4 does allow for a primarily enjoyable experience. Most of the bad episodes aren't even that bad, though there are a few stinkers here and there. As a whole, I would consider Season 4 to be a good season, but not nearly on the same stances of the first three seasons. It's still filled with plenty of classic moments, but you can definitely notice a downturn in quality here. I already gave my top 5 and that hasn't changed. I will, however, give my Bottom 5, because I can do that now.

5.) "All That Glitters" - Nothing abysmal, but the moral seems pretty shoehorned in, and the episode doesn't really have the amount of laughs to satisfy. It could definitely be worse, but I still wouldn't say I like the episode.
4.) "Squid Wood" - A typical bad "The World Hates Squidward" episode (can we seriously stop calling them Squid torture?) that has jokes here and there, but not enough to really satisfy it being "good" or even "meh." Feels a little too unfair to Squidward at times.
3.) "Wigstruck" - This is the only episode this season I can't really understand what they were trying to do. For each other episode, I can understand what they were going for, but this just baffles me. Was the wig supposed to be funny? Don't get me wrong, it's not abysmal, but still not good.
2.) "The Thing" - This episode mostly just has be feeling bad for Squidward without really giving him a reason for any of the harm he faces. In some cases this can be funny, but the jokes typically miss their mark, and the episode just feels... unpleasant.
1.) "Good Neighbors" - Far from the worst of the series, but a really bad episode nonetheless. It's really unfunny, and Squidward gets a lot of unnecessary pain which is... common in bad Season 4 episodes.

As a whole these episodes can be... worse, but they're a huge step down from even the bad Season 1-3 episodes. Nonetheless, I don't think a handful of bad and meh episodes really warrants a bad, or even "Meh" season. Season 4 as a whole, is good in my book.
 

Squidward1984

New Member


14 posts
$35 doubloons
·Fear Of A Krabby Patty - A - Great story, funny, nice atmosphere. A great start to the season.

·Shell Of A Man - A - Had an excellent story and was funny.

·The Lost Mattress - A+ - Great story, hilarious, great atmosphere.

·Krabs vs. Plankton - A+ - Excellent story, funny, nice atmosphere.

·Have You Seen This Snail? - A - Excellent story, relatable and awesome atmosphere. Not that funny though.

·Skill Crane - A+ - Excellent story, relatable and hilarious.

·Good Neighbors - B+ - Besides the ending, I thought this episode was pretty good. It was very funny and had a pretty good atmosphere. However the story was pretty weak and the ending is pretty annoying. Other than that, I think this episode was pretty good and I think it's a little too overhated.

·Selling Out - A - Excellent story and nice atmosphere. Not that funny though.

·Funny Pants - B - Had a good story and Patrick was hilarious. Other than that, it's pretty annoying.

·Dunces and Dragons - B+ - Had a great story and awesome atmosphere. Wasn't that funny though and Squidly was kinda annoying.

·Enemy In-Law - A - Excellent story, nice atmosphere and was pretty funny.

·Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - A - Had an excellent story and was pretty funny.

·Patrick Smartpants - A - Excellent story, funny and nice atmosphere.

·SquidBob TentaclePants - A - Great story, occasionally funny, nice atmosphere.

·Krusty Towers - A+ - Great story, hilarious and awesome atmosphere. Everyone had a great role.

·Mrs. Puff, Your Fired - A+ - Best of the season. Hilarious, excellent story, awesome atmosphere. Sergeant Rodrick was great.

·Ghost Host - A+ - Great story, hilarious, awesome atmosphere. My profile picture says it all.

·Chimps Ahoy - A+ - Great story, funny and great atmosphere. Patrick was hilarious.

·Whale Of A Birthday - A- - Had an excellent story and was pretty funny. However, I did not like the "Boys Who Cry" and I thought it was pretty weird for Squidward to like them.

·Karate Island - A+ - Had a great story and an awesome atmosphere. Also had some awesome action scenes.

·All That Glitters - C - Not that funny, kinda sad, and didn't have a very good plot.

·Wishing You Well - A+ - Hilarious, great story, awesome atmosphere.

·New Leaf - A - Great story, occasionally funny and nice atmosphere.

·Once Bitten - A - Great story, funny and nice atmosphere.

·Bummer Vacation - A+ - Excellent story, funny and nice atmosphere.

·Wigstruck - C+ - Not a very good story and Spongebob was pretty annoying. Wasn't that funny either. The ending was pretty good though.

·Squidtastic Voyage - A+ - Excellent story, funny and awesome atmosphere.

·That's No Lady - A - Great story, funny and nice atmosphere. Mr. Krabs and Squidward were funny here.

·The Thing - A - Good story, funny, great atmosphere. Kinda sad though.

·Hocus Pocus - A- - Great story, occasionally funny, nice atmosphere.

·Driven To Tears - A+ - Excellent story, funny and great atmosphere.

·Rule Of Dumb - A+ - Great story, hilarious, nice atmosphere.

·Born To Be Wild - C- - Not a good story and not very funny. The ending was pretty good though.

·Best Frenimies - A+ - Excellent story, hilarious, awesome atmosphere.

·The Pink Purloiner - A+ - Great story, funny and nice atmosphere.

·Squid Wood - C- - Had a decent, but cruel story and everyone was pretty mean and it was kinda sad.

·Best Day Ever - A - Excellent story, occasionally funny and nice atmosphere. The song was pretty good.

·The Gift Of Gum - A+ - Great story, funny, awesome atmosphere.


My Top 5.

5. Ghost Host.
4. The Lost Mattress.
3. Best Frenimies.
2. Krusty Towers.
1. Mrs. Puff, Your Fired.

My Bottom 5.

5. Funny Pants
4. Wigstruck
3. All That Glitters
2. Born To Be Wild
1. Squid Wood
 

TheGreatServer

NOT a Bunny now!


1,439 posts
$2,484 doubloons
Fear of a Krabby Patty - Good
Shell of a Man - Great
The Lost Mattress - Good
Krabs vs. Plankton - Amazing
Have You Seen This Snail? - Decent
Skill Crane - Amazing
Good Neighbors - Mediocre
Selling Out - Good
Funny Pants - Meh
Dunces and Dragons - Perfect
Enemy in Law - Okay
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - Great
Patrick SmartPants - Good
SquidBob TentaclePants - Great
Krusty Towers - Great
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - Amazing
Ghost Host - Decent
Chimps Ahoy - Meh
Whale of a Birthday - Meh
Karate Island - Good
All That Glitters - Mediocre
Wishing You Well - Good
New Leaf - Okay
Once Bitten - Good
Bummer Vacation - Good
Wigstruck - Mediocre
Squidtastic Voyage - Great
That's No Lady - Great
The Thing - Okay
Hocus Pocus - Decent
Driven to Tears - Good
Rule of Dumb - Meh
Born to Be Wild - Good
Best Frenemies - Good
The Pink Purloiner - Perfect
Squid Wood - Bad
Best Day Ever - Good
The Gift of Gum - Good

GOOD SEASON

Bottom 5

5. Whale of a Birthday
4. Wigstruck
3. Good Neighbors
2. All That Glitters
1. Squid Wood

Top 5

5. Mrs. Puff, You're Fired
4. Skill Crane
3. Krabs vs. Plankton
2. Dunces and Dragons
1. The Pink Purloiner
 

Depressed Luigi

I'm proud of you guys


1,692 posts
$46 doubloons
Fear of a Krabby Patty (A+)
Shell of a Man (A)
The Lost Mattress (A+)
Krabs vs Plankton (A)
Have you Seen This Snail? (A+)
Skill Crane (A+)
Good Neighbors (E)
Selling Out (A)
Funny Pants (D)
Dunces and Dragons (A+)
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture (D)
Enemy In-Law (A-)
Patrick Smartpants (C)
SquidBob TentaclePants (C-)
Krusty Towers (A+)
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired (A+)
Chimps Ahoy (B)
Ghost Host (B)
Whale of a Birthday (B+)
Karate Island (A)
All That Glitters (D)
Wishing You Well (A+)
New Leaf (B)
Once Bitten (B+)
Bummer Vacation (B)
Wigstruck (E)
Squidtastic Voyage (B+)
That's No Lady (B+)
Hocus Pocus (C+)
The Thing (F)
Driven to Tears (B-)
Rule of Dumb (D)
Best Frenemies (B+)
Born to be Wild (C+)
The Pink Purlonior (A)
Squid Wood (F)
Best Day Ever (A-)
The Gift of Gum (E)

8 Amazing (8 A+)
7 Great (5 A, 2 A-)
9 Good (5 B+, 4 B)
1 Decent (1 B-, 0 C+)
3 Average (2 C+, 1 C)
4 Meh (1 C-, 3 D)
3 Bad (3 E)
3 Terrible (3 F, (0 F-)
0 Atrocius (0 F-)(0 Z)

Top 5:
1: Krusty Towers
2: Dunces and Dragons
3: Wishing you Well
4: Skill Crane
5: Have you Seen this Snail?

Bottom 5:
1: Squid Wood
2: The Thing
3: Good Neighbors
4: Wigstruck
5: The Gift of Gum

Underrated:
  • Enemy In-Law
  • Best Day Ever
  • Karate Island
  • Krabs vs Plankton
  • Whale of a Birthday
Overrated:
  • Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture
  • Patrick Smartpants
  • The Gift of Gum
  • Squidbob Tentaclepants
Notes:

Rating Rainbow:
1.Krusty Towers (A+)
2.Dunces and Dragons (A+)
3.Wishing You Well (A+)
4.Skill Crane (A+)
5.Have You Seen This Snail (A+)
6.Fear of a Krabby Patty (A+)
7.Mrs. Puff, You're Fired (A+)
8.The Lost Mattress (A+)
9.The Pink Purlonior (A)
10.Krabs vs Plankton (A)
11.Selling Out (A)
12.Shell of a Man (A)
13.Karate Island (A)
14.Enemy In-Law (A-)
15.Best Day Ever (A-)
16.Best Frenemies (B+)
17.Whale of a Birthday (B+)
18.Once Bitten (B+)
19.That's No Lady (B+)
20.Squidtastic Voyage (B+)
21.Ghost Host (B)
22.New Leaf (B)
23.Bummer Vacation (B)
24.Chimps Ahoy (B)
25.Driven to Tears (B-)
26.Born to be Wild (C+)
27.Hocus Pocus (C+)
28.Patrick Smartpants (C)
29.Squidbob Tentaclepants (C-)
30.Rule of Dumb (D)
31.Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture (D)
32.Funny Pants (D)
33.All That Glitters (D)
34.The Gift of Gum (E)
35.Wigstruck (E)
36.Good Neighbers (E)
37.The Thing (F)
38.Squid Wood (F)
 

jack_of_all_traids

I give up.


1,311 posts
$594 doubloons
Fear Of A Krabby Patty (A+)
Shell Of A Man (C)
The Lost Mattress (A)
Krabs Vs. Plankton (B)
Have You Seen This Snail? (A)
Skill Crane (B)
Good Neighbors (E)
Selling Out (A)
Funny Pants (B)
Dunces And Dragons (A++)
Enemy In-Law (C)
Mermaid Man And Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture (A)
Patrick SmartPants (B)
SquidBob TentaclePants (C)
Krusty Towers (A+)
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired (A++)
Ghost Host (B)
Chimps Ahoy (B)
Whale Of A Birthday (B)
Karate Island (D)
All That Glitters (F)
Wishing You Well (A+)
New Leaf (B)
Once Bitten (A)
Bummer Vacation (A+)
Wigstruck (E)
Squidtastic Voyage (A)
That's No Lady (B)
The Thing (F)
Hocus Pocus (D)
Driven To Tears (B)
Rule Of Dumb (D)
Born To Be Wild (C)
Best Frenemies (A)
The Pink Purloiner (A)
Squid Wood (F)
Best Day Ever (Reconsidering)
The Gift Of Gum (C)

Slightly worse than Season 3, but has my favorite style of animation.

Top 5:
5. Wishing You Well
4. Bummer Vacation
3. Krusty Towers
2. Dunces And Dragons
1. Mrs. Puff, You're Fired

Bottom 5:
5. Good Neighbors
4. Wigstruck
3. Squid Wood
2. The Thing
1. All That Glitters
 
Top