Pinned thread Season 4 Discussion

MASTER OF BIKINI BOTTOM XD

Part Computer or Something
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
53
Location
Naucalpan, Mexico
UNDERATED SEASON, I used to mistake some episodes in this one with Season 3

Fear of a Krabby Patty 9.9/10
Shell of a Man 9.8/10
The Lost Mattress 9.7/10

Krabs vs Plankton 9.5/10
Have You Seen This Snail? 9.8/10
Skill Crane 9.4/10
Good Neighbors 8.3/10
Selling Out 9.5/10
Funny Pants 8.8/10
Dunces and Dragons 9.8/10
Enemy In-Law 9.5/10
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture 9.5/10
Patrick SmartPants 9.5/10

SquidBob TentaclePants 8.7/10
Krusty Towers 9.8/10
Mrs. Puff Your Fired 9.3/10
Chimps Ahoy 9.5/10
Ghost Host 9.4/10

Whale of a Birthday 8.9/10
Karate Island 9.2/10
All That Glitters 8.3/10
Wishing You Well 9.9/10
New Leaf 8.9/10
Once Bitten 9.3/10
Bummer Vacation 9.5/10

Wigstruck 8.6/10
Squidtastic Voyage 8. 8/10

That's No Lady 9.8/10
The Thing 8.3/10
Hocus Pocus 8.8/10
Driven to Tears 8.8/10
Rule of Dumb 8.7/10
Born to be Wild 8.9/10
Best Frenemies 9.5/10

The Pink Purloiner 9.8/10
Squid Wood 8.2/10
Best Day Ever 8.9/10
The Gift of Gum 8.7/10


Amazing:9
Great:14
Good:11
Okay:4
Meh:0
Mediocre:0
Bad:0
Awful:0
Terrible:0
Atrocity:0
Abysmal:0

Top 5
5 Krusty Towers
4 Shell of a Man
3 Have You Seen This Snail?
2 Wishing You Well
1 Fear of a Krabby Patty


Bottom 5
5 Wigstruck
4 The Thing
3 Good Neighbors
2 All That Glitters
1 Squid Wood


THIS IS THE MOST UNDERATED SEASON

I'M READY!!!
 
Last edited:
Joined
Sep 24, 2017
Messages
96
Location
United States
Fear Of A Krabby Patty - 7.5/10
Shell Of A Man - 7/10
The Lost Mattress - 8/10
Krabs Vs Plankton - 7/10
Have You Seen This Snail? - 6/10
Skill Crane - 6/10
Good Neighbors - 3/10
Selling Out - 7.5/10
Funny Pants - 3.5/10
Dunces And Dragons - 8/10
Enemy In-Law - 3.5/10
Mermaidman And Barnacleboy VI: The Motion Picture - 7.5/10
Patrick SmartPants - 6.5/10
SquidBob TentaclePants - 7.5/10
Krusty Towers - 7.5/10
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - 7.5/10
Chimps Ahoy - 7.5/10
Ghost Host - 7.5/10
Whale Of A Birthday - 5.5/10
Karate Island - 8/10
All That Glitters - 7.5/10
Wishing You Well - 6.5/10
New Leaf - 5/10
Once Bitten - 7.5/10
Bummer Vacation - 5.5/10
Wigstruck - 7.5/10
Squidtastic Voyage - 7.5/10
That's No Lady - 3.5/10
The Thing - 6.5/10
Hocus Pocus - 3/10
Driven To Tears - 6.5/10
Rule Of Dumb - 8/10
Born To Be Wild - 1.5/10
Best Frenemies - 7.5/10
The Pink Purloiner - 5.5/10
Squid Wood - 4.5/10
Best Day Ever - 8/10
The Gift Of Gum - 8/10
 

Pugs4Thugs

Gary the Snail Supremacist
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
764
Location
Far Away
Fear of a Krabby Patty: 9.3/10
Shell of a Man: 7.6/10
The Lost Mattress: 8.4/10
Krabs Vs. Plankton: 7.3/10
Have You Seen This Snail?: 8.8/10
Skill Crane: 7/10
Good Neighbors: 3.5/10
Selling Out: 8/10
Funny Pants: 4.5/10
Dunces and Dragons: 9/10
Enemy-in-Law: 5.4/10
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture: 7.3/10
Patrick SmartPants: 6/10
SquidBob Tentacle Pants: 6.7/10
Krusty Towers: 9.3/10
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired: 7.2/10
Chimps Ahoy: 6/10
Ghost Host: 8.8/10
Whale of a Birthday: 7.3/10
Karate Island: 8.6/10
All That Glitters: 6.4/10
Wishing You Well: 7.4/10
New Leaf: 8.6/10
Once Bitten: 9/10
Bummer Vacation: 4/10
Wigstruck: 4.3/10
Squidtastic Voyage: 5/10
That's No Lady: 7/10
​The Thing: 3.5/10
Hocus Pocus: 6/10
Driven to Tears: 4.6/10
Rule of Dumb: 7/10
Born to be Wild: 6/10
Best Frenemies: 9.2/10
The Pink Purloiner: 7.6/10
Squid Wood: 7/10
Best Day Ever: 7.8/10
The Gift of Gum: 5.2/10

Top 5:
5. Once Bitten
4. Dunces and Dragons
3. Best Frenemies
2. Krusty Towers
1. Fear of a Krabby Patty

Bottom 5:
5. Funny Pants
4. Wigstruck
3. Bummer Vacation
2. The Thing
1. Good Neighbors

Scoring:
Amazing: 5
Great: 6
Good: 12
Okay: 6
Mediocre: 3
Bad: 4
Atrocity: 2
Abysmal: 0

Season 4 was a mixed bag of good and bad, which makes sense. This season was like a transition into the bad seasons of SpongeBob.
 

Klu

Moby Dollar
Joined
Apr 22, 2017
Messages
467
Location
Яussia
Fear Of A Krabby Patty - Really Good
Shell Of A Man - Really Good
The Lost Mattress - Really Good
Krabs Vs Plankton - Really Good
Have You Seen This Snail? - Really Good
Skill Crane - Really Good
Good Neighbors - Awful
Selling Out - Good
Funny Pants - meh
Dunces And Dragons - Really Good
Enemy In-Law - Good
Mermaidman And Barnacleboy VI: The Motion Picture - Really Good
Patrick SmartPants - Really Good
SquidBob TentaclePants - meh
Krusty Towers - Really Good
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - Good
Chimps Ahoy - Good and underrated
Ghost Host - Good and underrated [2]
Whale Of A Birthday - Good, bit of a guilty pleasure
Karate Island - Good
All That Glitters - Awful piece of garbage, one of the worst in entire show
Wishing You Well - Really Good
New Leaf - meh
Once Bitten - meh
Bummer Vacation - Really Good
Wigstruck - meh with shades of trash
Squidtastic Voyage - Good
That's No Lady - meh
The Thing - Awful
Hocus Pocus - Good
Driven To Tears - Good
Rule Of Dumb - meh
Born To Be Wild - Really good and underrated [3]
Best Frenemies - Really good
The Pink Purloiner - Really good and underrated [4]
Squid Wood - Awful
Best Day Ever - meh
The Gift Of Gum - Awful

Really nostalgic season for me, I like it a lot, but has some flaws like season 5. But season 4 a little bit stronger in my book - 8/10.
 

Honest Slug

Ink Lemonade hurts me.
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
4,255
Location
Washington
Fear of a Krabby Patty - 10/10
Shell of a Man - 9/10
The Lost Mattress - 9/10
Krabs vs. Plankton - 8/10
Have You Seen This Snail? - 8/10
Skill Crane - 8/10
Good Neighbors - 3/10
Selling Out - 5/10
Funny Pants - 5/10
Dunces and Dragons - 10/10
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI - 9/10
Enemy In-law - 4/10
Patrick SmartPants - 8/10
SquidBob TentaclePants - 6/10
Krusty Towers - 10/10
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - 10/10
Chimps Ahoy - 7/10
Ghost Host - 7/10
Whale of a Birthday - 6/10
Karate Island - 8/10
All That Glitters - 1/10
Wishing You Well - 8/10
New Leaf - 5/10
Once Bitten - 8/10
Bummer Vacation - 7/10
Wigstruck - 5/10
Squidtastic Voyage - 4/10
That's No Lady - 7/10
The Thing - 2/10
Hocus Pocus - 6/10
Driven to Tears - 7/10
Rule of Dumb - 4/10
Born To Be Wild - 6/10
Best Frenemies - 7/10
The Pink Purloiner - 10/10
Squid Wood - 2/10
Best Day Ever - 5/10
The Gift of Gum - 3/10

Top 5
1. Dunces and Dragons
2. Fear of a Krabby Patty
3. The Pink Purloiner
4. Krusty Towers
5. Mrs. Puff, You're Fired

Bottom 5
1. All That Glitters
2. Squid Wood
3. The Thing
4. Good Neighbors
5. The Gift of Gum
 
Joined
Feb 23, 2018
Messages
41
Location
Naucalpan, Mexico
Rainbow Form!!!

1 Dunces and Dragons (A+)
2 Fear of a Krabby Patty (A+)
3 Wishing You Well (A+)
4 Krusty Towers (A+)
5 The Pink Purloiner (A)
6 That's No Lady (A)
7 Have You Seen this Snail? (A)
8 Patrick SmartPants (A-)
9 Bummer Vacation (A-)
10 The Lost Matress (A-)
11 Ghost Host (A-)
12 Enemy In-Law (A-)
13 Born to be Wild (A-)
14 Seling Out (A-)
15 Shell of a Man (A-)
16 Once Bitten (A-)
17 Mrs. Puff, Your Fired (A-)
18 Skill Crane (A-)
19 Chimps Ahoy (A-)
20 Best Frenemies (A-)
21 Krabs vs Plankton (A-)
22 Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture (A-)
23 Karate Island (B+)
24 Hocus Pocus (B)
25 Best Day Ever (B)
26 The Gift of Gum (B)
27 New Leaf (B)
28 Funny Pants (B)
29 SquidBob TentaclePants (B)
30 Whale of a Birthday (B)
31 Squidtastic Voyage (B)
32 Driven to Tears (B)
33 Wigstruck (B)
34 All That Glitters (B-)
35 Rule of Dumb (B-)
36 The Thing (B-)
37 Good Neighbors (B-)
38 Squid Wood (B-)

I'M READY!!!
 

hippythehippo

Banished
Joined
Apr 21, 2018
Messages
259
Location
Mall of America, Minnesota
Going off of memory here since I don't want to watch a season I don't like, nor do I have the patience or time.


Fear of a Krabby Patty 8/10
Shell of a Man 8/10
The Lost Mattress 7/10
Krabs vs Plankton 8/10
Have You Seen this Snail 8/10
Skill Crane 8/10
Good Neighbors 2/10
Selling Out 5/10 (perfect title though)
Funny Pants 4/10
Dunces and Dragons 10/10
Enemy In-Law 6/10
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy VI 7/10
Patrick Smartpants 9/10
Squidbob Tentaclepants 5/10
Krusty Towers 10/10
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired 7/10
Ghost Host 7/10
Chimps Ahoy 6/10
Whale of a Birthday 5/10
Karate Island 5/10
All That Glitters 3/10
Wishing You Well 9/10
New Leaf 5/10
Once Bitten 5/10
Bummer Vacation 9/10
Wigstruck 4/10
Squidtastic Voyage 4/10
That's No Lady 5/10
The Thing 3/10
Hocus Pocus 4/10
Driven to Tears 6/10
Rule of Dumb 4/10
Born to Be Wild 4/10
Best Frenemies 8/10
The Pink Purloiner 9/10
Squid Wood 4/10
Best Day Ever 5/10
The Gift of Gum 5/10

16 Good episodes
12 Meh episodes
10 Bad episodes

The season started of strong, and ran out of steam half way through. The ideas towards the end felt generic and half baked. The thing that surprised me the most was that out of the last half, I only liked 4 out of the 19 episodes. If the beginning wasn't as good as it was, I would have given this season a bad. Still a middling season, and nowhere near the original run. One thing of note is that throughout the season, even through the beginning, the episodes seem to take themselves way to seriously. The atmosphere seems off, which might explain why I don't like a large chunk of the season. I'm sure that most of 9b would have fallen flat too if it wasn't for the atmosphere. Overall though, a pretty disappointing season, and a downfall from the great season 3.
 

Coffee_lover

Banished
Joined
Dec 3, 2017
Messages
266
Location
Ukraine
1)Krusty Towers(A+)
2))Have you Seen This Snail?(A+)
3)Dunces and Dragons(A+)
4)Fear of a Krabby Patty(A+)
5)Skill Crane(A+)
6)Wising you Well(A+)
7)MermaidMan and BarnacleBoy VI:TMP(A+)
8)The Pink Purloined(A+)
9)Patrick Smartpants(A+)
10)Mrs. Puff,You’re Fired(A+)
11)The Lost Mattress(A)
12)Bumper Vacation(A)
13)Best Frenemies(A)
14)Selling Out(A)
15)Drive to Tears(A)
16)Ghost Host(A)
17)Krabs vs Plankton(A)
18)Shell of a Man(A-)
19)Enemy In-Law(A-)
20)Hocus Pocus(A-)
21)Squid Wood(A-)
22)Once Bitten(B+)
23)Funny Pants(B+)
24)Rule of Dumb(B+)
25)Squidbob Tentaclepants(B+)
26)The Gift of Gum(B+)
27)Born to be Wild(B)
28)Chimps Ahoy(B)
29)Karate Island(B)
30)Whale of Birthday(B-)
31)Best Day Ever(B-)
32)That’s no Lady(C+)
33)Wigstruck(C)
34)Good Neighbors(C-)
35)New Leaf(C-)
36)All that Glitters(D+)
37)Squidtastic Voyage(D+)
38)The Thing(D)

Overall Though:Slightly weaker than previous seasons,but still really solid,definitely not "gARbaGe BEcAuse iT’s ISn’T PrE-MoVIe sEAson”.Number of bad episodes also increased a little,but the only one that I think is completely failing is The Thing,while the best episodes being as good as 1-3S material(I think that Krusty Towers is the funniest episode of all time)


Rating:(A-)
 
Joined
Dec 20, 2017
Messages
63
My thoughts on Season 4:

Fear of a Krabby Patty - A-
Shell of a Man - A-
The Lost Mattress - A+
Krabs vs. Plankton - B-
Have You Seen This Snail? - A+
Skill Crane - A-
Good Neighbors - E
Selling Out - B
Funny Pants - D+
Dunces and Dragons - A+ (best)
Enemy In-Law - B+
Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - A+
Patrick SmartPants - B+
SquidBob TentaclePants - B-
Krusty Towers - A+
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - A
Chimps Ahoy - A (extremely underrated)
Ghost Host - C-
Whale of a Birthday - C
Karate Island - B-
All That Glitters - E
Wishing You Well - A
New Leaf - D+
Once Bitten - E
Bummer Vacation - D+ (didn’t like it, sorry)
Wigstruck - D
Squidtastic Voyage - B (another underrated episode)
That's No Lady - C+
The Thing - F
Hocus Pocus - D
Driven to Tears - D+
Rule of Dumb - D-
Born to Be Wild - C
Best Frenemies - A+
The Pink Purloiner - B-
Squid Wood - F- (worst)
Best Day Ever - C-
The Gift of Gum - C-

0 PERFECT! episodes
6 Magnificent episodes
3 Amazing episodes
3 Superb episodes
2 Great episodes
2 Good episodes
4 Decent episodes
1 Okay episode
2 Meh episodes
3 Mediocre episodes
4 Poor episodes
2 Bad episodes
1 Awful episode
0 Terrible episodes
3 Unsatisfactory episodes
0 Vile episodes
0 Heinous episode
1 Horrendous episode
1 Abhorrent episode
0 SCUMBOB! episodes

I think Season 4 is an Okay season. It has its ups and downs. The quality was really good during the first few episodes but after All That Glitters premiered, the rest of the season went downhill with episodes that were bland, pointless, and cruel. Not bad though, but not one of my favorites either.

Top 5
5. The Lost Mattress
4. Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture
3. Have You Seen This Snail?
2. Krusty Towers
1. Dunces and Dragons

Bottom 5
5. All That Glitters
4. Good Neighbors
3. Once Bitten
2. The Thing
1. Squid Wood
 

Honest Slug

Ink Lemonade hurts me.
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
4,255
Location
Washington
Tyler730 said:
My thoughts on Season 4:

Fear of a Krabby Patty - A-
Shell of a Man - A-
The Lost Mattress - A+
Krabs vs. Plankton - B-
Have You Seen This Snail? - A+
Skill Crane - A-
Good Neighbors - E
Selling Out - B
Funny Pants - D+
Dunces and Dragons - A+ (best)
Enemy In-Law - B+
Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - A+
Patrick SmartPants - B+
SquidBob TentaclePants - B-
Krusty Towers - A+
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - A
Chimps Ahoy - A (extremely underrated)
Ghost Host - C-
Whale of a Birthday - C
Karate Island - B-
All That Glitters - E
Wishing You Well - A
New Leaf - D+
Once Bitten - E
Bummer Vacation - D+ (didn’t like it, sorry)
Wigstruck - D
Squidtastic Voyage - B (another underrated episode)
That's No Lady - C+
The Thing - F
Hocus Pocus - D
Driven to Tears - D+
Rule of Dumb - D-
Born to Be Wild - C
Best Frenemies - A+
The Pink Purloiner - B-
Squid Wood - F- (worst)
Best Day Ever - C-
The Gift of Gum - C-

0 PERFECT! episodes
6 Magnificent episodes
3 Amazing episodes
3 Superb episodes
2 Great episodes
2 Good episodes
4 Decent episodes
1 Okay episode
2 Meh episodes
3 Mediocre episodes
4 Poor episodes
2 Bad episodes
1 Awful episode
0 Terrible episodes
3 Unsatisfactory episodes
0 Vile episodes
0 Heinous episode
1 Horrendous episode
1 Abhorrent episode
0 SCUMBOB! episodes

I think Season 4 is an Okay season. It has its ups and downs. The quality was really good during the first few episodes but after All That Glitters premiered, the rest of the season went downhill with episodes that were bland, pointless, and cruel. Not bad though, but not one of my favorites either.

Top 5
5. The Lost Mattress
4. Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture
3. Have You Seen This Snail?
2. Krusty Towers
1. Dunces and Dragons

Bottom 5
5. All That Glitters
4. Good Neighbors
3. Once Bitten
2. The Thing
1. Squid Wood
Please do this for other seasons.
 

hippythehippo

Banished
Joined
Apr 21, 2018
Messages
259
Location
Mall of America, Minnesota
Tyler730 said:
My thoughts on Season 4:

Fear of a Krabby Patty - A-
Shell of a Man - A-
The Lost Mattress - A+
Krabs vs. Plankton - B-
Have You Seen This Snail? - A+
Skill Crane - A-
Good Neighbors - E
Selling Out - B
Funny Pants - D+
Dunces and Dragons - A+ (best)
Enemy In-Law - B+
Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture - A+
Patrick SmartPants - B+
SquidBob TentaclePants - B-
Krusty Towers - A+
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired - A
Chimps Ahoy - A (extremely underrated)
Ghost Host - C-
Whale of a Birthday - C
Karate Island - B-
All That Glitters - E
Wishing You Well - A
New Leaf - D+
Once Bitten - E
Bummer Vacation - D+ (didn’t like it, sorry)
Wigstruck - D
Squidtastic Voyage - B (another underrated episode)
That's No Lady - C+
The Thing - F
Hocus Pocus - D
Driven to Tears - D+
Rule of Dumb - D-
Born to Be Wild - C
Best Frenemies - A+
The Pink Purloiner - B-
Squid Wood - F- (worst)
Best Day Ever - C-
The Gift of Gum - C-

0 PERFECT! episodes
6 Magnificent episodes
3 Amazing episodes
3 Superb episodes
2 Great episodes
2 Good episodes
4 Decent episodes
1 Okay episode
2 Meh episodes
3 Mediocre episodes
4 Poor episodes
2 Bad episodes
1 Awful episode
0 Terrible episodes
3 Unsatisfactory episodes
0 Vile episodes
0 Heinous episode
1 Horrendous episode
1 Abhorrent episode
0 SCUMBOB! episodes

I think Season 4 is an Okay season. It has its ups and downs. The quality was really good during the first few episodes but after All That Glitters premiered, the rest of the season went downhill with episodes that were bland, pointless, and cruel. Not bad though, but not one of my favorites either.

Top 5
5. The Lost Mattress
4. Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy VI: The Motion Picture
3. Have You Seen This Snail?
2. Krusty Towers
1. Dunces and Dragons

Bottom 5
5. All That Glitters
4. Good Neighbors
3. Once Bitten
2. The Thing
1. Squid Wood
Your rating for the season overall seems rather strange. If the average for all the episodes is 6.5.....that's actually a pretty good average. Remember, this is 38 episodes of varying quality (for reference, I think there are 20 good Season 9b eps, but the average is around a 6.48). I think amount of good eps compared o meh and bad give the Season a more fair chance, rather than averages, which could be misleading. (I mean, I don't even like the Season anyway lmao)
 
Joined
Dec 20, 2017
Messages
63
Please do this for other seasons.
I’m currently working on Season 5.
Your rating for the season overall seems rather strange. If the average for all the episodes is 6.5.....that's actually a pretty good average. Remember, this is 38 episodes of varying quality (for reference, I think there are 20 good Season 9b eps, but the average is around a 6.48). I think amount of good eps compared o meh and bad give the Season a more fair chance, rather than averages, which could be misleading. (I mean, I don't even like the Season anyway lmao)
I suppose I could’ve had a better description. It is more on the upper side than the lower.
 

sthom

the guy who draws the toons
Joined
Oct 8, 2018
Messages
44
Fear of a Krabby Patty- 9/10
Shell of a Man- 5.5/10
The Lost Mattress- 6/10
Krabs vs Plankton- 8/10
Have You Seen This Snail- 6/10
Skill Crane- 8/10
Good Neighbors- 4/10
Selling Out- 8/10
Funny Pants- 5/10
Dunces and Dragons- 9/10
Enemy In-Law- 8/10
MM&BB VI- 8/10
Patrick Smartpants- 8/10
Krusty Towers- 9/10
Mrs. Puff You're Fired- 9/10
Chimps Ahoy- 8/10
Ghost Host- 8/10
Whale of a Birthday- 7/10
Karate Island- 4/10
All That Glitters- 3.5/10
Wishing You Well- 6/10
New Leaf- 7/10
Once Bitten- 7/10
Bummer Vacation- 5/10
Wigstruck- 3/10
Squidtastic Voyage- 8/10
That's No Lady- 8/10
The Thing- 2.5/10
Hocus Pocus- 8/10
Driven to Tears- 3.5/10
Rule of Dumb- 9/10
Born To Be Wild- 7/10
Best Frenemies- 8/10
Pink Purloiner- 8/10
Squid Wood- 7/10
Best Day Ever- 8/10
Gift of Gum- 6/10

Not the greatest, but not as bad as people make it out to be.
 

Octavionknox888

Giant Clam
Joined
Dec 21, 2018
Messages
323
Location
here
Ratings: 10- Outstanding
9- Amazing
8- Great
7- Good
6- Decent
5- Ok
4- Mediocre
3- Bad
2- Horrible
1- Terrible

Now let's go on to the episodes!

Fear of a Krabby Patty: Outstanding
Shell of a Man: Amazing
The Lost Mattress: Great but close to Amazing
Krabs vs. Plankton: Amazing
Have you Seen this Snail?: Outstanding
Skill Crane: Outstanding
Good Neighbors: Mediocre
Selling Out: Good but close to Great
Funny Pants: Ok
Dungeons & Dragons: Outstanding
Enemy in Law: Good
Mermaidman and barnacleboy 6: The Motion Picture: Good
Patrick Smartpants: Outstanding
Squidbob Tentaclepants: Outstanding
Krusty Towers: Outstanding
Mrs. Puff You're Fired: Amazing but close to Outstanding
Chimps Ahoy: Good
Ghost Host: Good but close to Decent
Whale of a Birthday: Outstanding
Karate Island: Decent
All That Glitters: Good but close to Decent
Wishing you Well: Outstanding but close to Amazing
New Leaf: Great
Once Bitten: Ok
Bummber Vacation: Amazing but close to Outstanding
Wigstruck: Decent but close to Good
Squidtastic Voyage: Outstanding
That's No Lady: Good
The Thing: Mediocre but close to Bad
Hocus Pocus: Good
Driven to Tears: Ok but close to Mediocre
Rule of Dumb: Ok but close to Decent
Born to Be Wild: Great but close to Amazing
Best Frenemies: Amazing but close to Outstanding
The Pink Purloiner: Amazing
Squid Wood: Mediocre but close to Ok
Best Day Ever: Good
The Gift of Gum: Mediocre but close to Bad

9 Outstanding
1 Outstanding but close to Amazing
3 Amazing but close to Outstanding
3 Amazing
2 Great but close to Amazing
1 Great
3 Good but close to Great/Decent
6 Good
1 Decent but close to Good
1 Decent
2 Ok but close to Decent/Mediocre
2 Ok
3 Mediocre but close to Ok/Bad
1 Mediocre
No Bad
No Horrible
0 Terrible

Overall, Great Season!
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 10, 2017
Messages
1,376
Location
United States
Fear of a Krabby Patty (A)
Shell of a Man (C)
The Lost Mattress (A)
Krabs vs. Plankton (B)
Have You Seen This Snail? (A)
Skill Crane (A)
Good Neighbors (D)
Selling Out (B)
Funny Pants (D)
Dunces and Dragons (A+)
Enemy In-Law (C)
Motion Picture (A)
Patrick SmartPants (A)
SquidBob TentaclePants (C)
Krusty Towers (A+)
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired (A)
Ghost Host (B)
Chimps Ahoy (C)
Whale of a Birthday (C)
Karate Island (D)
All That Glitters (F-)
Wishing You Well (A)
New Leaf (C)
Once Bitten (B)
Bummer Vacation (A)
Wigstruck (D)
Squidtastic Voyage (B)
That's No Lady (B)
The Thing (E)
Hocus Pocus (C)
Driven to Tears (C)
Rule of Dumb (D)
Born to be Wild (C)
Best Frenemies (B)
The Pink Purloiner (A)
Squid Wood (E)
Best Day Ever (C)
The Gift of Gum (C)

Top 5:
5. Have You Seen This Snail?
4. Wishing You Well
3. Mrs. Puff, You're Fired
2. Krusty Towers
1. Dunces and Dragons

Bottom 5:
5. Rule of Dumb
4. Good Neighbors
3. Squid Wood
2. The Thing
1. All That Glitters
 

Sealand

Part Computer or Something
Joined
Jun 13, 2019
Messages
33
Fear of a krabby patty: Masterpiece
Shell of a man: Masterpiece
The lost mattress: Amazing
Krabs vs plankton: Good
Skill crane: Amazing
Good neighbors: Excellent
Selling out: Great
Funny pants: Good
Enemy in-law: Excellent
Mermaidman and barnacleboy: The motion picture: Amazing
Patrick Smartpants: Excellent
Squidbob Tentaclepants: Good
Have you seen this snail: Masterpiece (2nd best episode in the SpongeBob franchise)
Dunces and dragons: Masterpiece
Krusty Towers: Amazing
Mrs puff, you're fired: Amazing
Ghost host: Good
Chimps ahoy: Okay
Karate island: Good
Whale of a birthday: Okay
All that glitters: Great
Wishing you well: Amazing
New Leaf: Amazing
Once bitten: Good
Bummer vacation: Excellent
Wigstruck: Mediocre
Squidtastic voyage: Amazing
That's no lady: Decent
Best day ever: Amazing
The thing: Decent
Hocus pocus: Okay
Rule of dumb: Excellent
Gift of the gum: Good
Squidwood: Mediocre
The pink polisher: Amazing
Driven to tears: Okay
Born to be wild: Good
Best frenemies: Great

Terrible episodes: None
Awful episodes: None
Bad episodes: None
Mediocre episodes: 2
Okay episodes: 4
Decent episodes: 2
Good episodes: 8
Great episodes: 3
Excellent episodes: 5
Amazing episodes: 10
Masterpiece episodes: 4

Rating: 98/100 Amazing season
 

CheeseCrocker

Moby Dollar
Joined
Jun 22, 2019
Messages
193
Fear of a Krabby Patty: Amazing
Shell of a Man: Good
The Lost Mattress: Amazing
Krabs vs. Plankton: Great
Have You Seen This Snail: Amazing
Skill Crane: Great
Good Neighbors: Great
Selling Out: Great
Funny Pants: Good
Dunces and Dragons: Amazing
Enemy In-Law: Great
MM and BB VI: TMP: Amazing
Patrick SmartPants: Amazing
SquidBob TentaclePants: Good
Krusty Towers: Amazing
Mrs. Puff, You're Fired: Amazing
Chimps Ahoy: Great
Ghost Host: Good
Whale of a Birthday: Amazing
Karate Island: Great
All That Glitters: Good
Wishing You Well: Great
New Leaf: Mediocre
Once Bitten: Great
Bummer Vacation: Great
Wigstruck: Great
Squidtastic Voyage: Great
That's No Lady: Great
The Thing: Good
Hocus Pocus: Great
Driven to Tears: Amazing
Rule of Dumb: Good
Born to Be Wild: Amazing
Best Frenemies: Great
The Pink Purloiner: Amazing
Squid Wood: Good
Best Day Ever: Good
The Gift of Gum: Great

This season is a truly great season, and it's really underrated. While it has some competition with season 3, it's better than that season because there are more greats in general and it contains my favorite episode of the series, Krusty Towers. My main reason for really liking this season is because it has really good stories, as well as great comedy. There's only one weak episode, but it isn't too bad and doesn't hinder the season that much. Overall this is my favorite season and honestly, this season gets better the more and more I watch it.
 
Last edited:

Captain Stupid

Giant Clam
Joined
Jun 12, 2014
Messages
306
Location
Stockholm
Season 4 is the first post-movie season, and I honestly see very little difference from Seasons 1-3. The only difference I noticed growing up was the improved animation and graphics.

I do unfortunately not consider Season 4 superior to it, but certainly in the same league.
Season 4 has, for the most part, finally been recognized as the brilliant season it actually was!

My opinion on each Season 4 episode:
Fear of a Krabby Patty: Great
Shell of a Man: Good
The Lost Mattress: Great
Krabs vs. Plankton: Good
Have You Seen This Snail?: Great
Skill Crane: Great
Good Neighbors: Okay (Yeah, I said that!)
Selling Out: Good
Funny Pants: Good
Dunces and Dragons: Good
Enemy in-Law: Okay
MermaidMan and BarnacleBoy VI - The Motion Picture: Good
Patrick Smartpants: Good
SquidBob TentaclePants: Good
Krusty Towers: Amazing
Mrs. Puff, you're Fired: Good
Chimps Ahoy: Amazing
Ghost Host: Amazing
Whale of a Birthday: Okay
Karate Island: Good
All That Glitters: Mediocre
Wishing You Well: Great
New Leaf: Great
Once Bitten: Amazing
Bummer Vacation: Okay
Wigstruck: Bad
Squidtastic Voyage: Okay
That's No Lady: Amazing
The Thing: Okay
Hocus Pocus: Okay
Driven to Tears: Good
Rule of Dumb: Good
Born to be Wild: Good
Best Frenemies: Great
The Pink Purloiner: Amazing (Best Post-Movie Episode!)
Squid Wood: Okay
Best Day Ever: Good
The Gift of Gum: Okay

Stats:
Amazing: 6
Great: 7
Good: 14
Okay: 9
Mediocre: 1
Bad: 1

Total:
27 Good Episodes
10 Meh Episodes
1 Bad Episode

Season Rating: Great Season

Top 10:

10. Best Frenemies
9. The Lost Mattress
8. Skill Crane
7. Fear of a Krabby Patty
6. Once Bitten
5. That's No Lady
4. Chimps Ahoy
3. Ghost Host
2. Krusty Towers
1. The Pink Purloiner! :whoo:

Unpopular opinions on Season 4:
  • The first half of Season 4 is better than the second half of Season 3. Yes, I said that.
  • Good Neighbors is NOT the "beginning of SpongeBob's downfall". It's not THAT bad! SpongeBob was portrayed better here than in Party Pooper Pants and The Great Snail Race, to say the least. In fact, I don't sympathize with Squidward at all.
  • None of the so called "Squidward Torture Episodes" in Season 4 bothered me at all.
  • Prior to Season 10, Season 4 was the best season from a visual standpoint.
  • No character is flanderized in this season.
Most overhated episode: Good Neighbors, The Thing and Squid Wood.
Most overrated episodes: Have You Seen this Snail?, Dunces and Dragons and Krusty Towers. (I do like all of them, don't get me wrong.)
Most underrated episodes: The Pink Purloiner, Chimps Ahoy, Ghost Host and Once Bitten.
Most underhated episode: Wigstruck.
 

Rex

Flying Dutchman's Sock
Joined
Sep 20, 2019
Messages
107
Location
County Carlow Ireland
Season 4b seriously drags down season 4.

Stats

4a

18 Episodes

3 Bad (Good Neighbors, Funny Pants, Chimps Ahoy)
0 Mediocre
2 Good (Mr's Puff Your'e Fired) (Selling Out)
4 Great (Motion Picture, Enemy In Law, Squidbob, Ghost Host)
9 Amazing (Fear Of A Krabby Patty, Shell Of A Man, The Lost Mattress, Krabs VS Plankton, Have You Seen This Snail?, Skill Crane, Dunces And Dragons, Patrick Smartpants, Krusty Towers)

4b

20 Episodes

8 Bad (All That Glitters, Once Bitten, Wigstruck, Squidtastic Voyage, Hocus Pocus, Rule Of Dumb, Squid Wood, Best Day Ever)
1 Mediocre (Whale Of A Birthday)
3 Good (New Leaf, The Thing, The Gift Of Gum)
3 Great (Karate Island, That's No Lady, Driven To Tears)
5 Amazing (Wishing You Well, Bummer Vacation, Best Frenemies, Born To Be Wild, The Pink Purloiner)

I still like Season 4 (7.5/10) But I do not really care for the second half as just under half of the episodes I like.
 
Last edited:

EdmundTheDevil

Part Computer or Something
Joined
Apr 29, 2020
Messages
42
Overall this is honestly my 3rd favorite season. I think it has more mediocre, poor and dreadful episodes than season 2 BUT I think season 4 has equally high highs but season 2 has a worse lower low then any of season 4's
 
Last edited:
Top