How surprising that I thought that this was a pre-movie episode! Well, it's not really a surprise, considering it's really awesome (and comparable)! The plot is great, the humor is excellent, and it tackles a certain fear that I can relate to. The best part is, it actually handles and resolves the subject in a silly, but solid and sensible way, unlike a certain episode revolving around the darkness...
Overall, barring Atlantis Squarepantis, this episode is my favorite Season 5 episode. And not only is it one of the best post-movie episodes, it's also one of my favorite episodes, PERIOD.
Season 5 is one of my favorite post-movie seasons of SBSP. This one, without a doubt, was fun and hilarious! This one featured a good helping of jokes and silly fun stuff on SpongeBob. I may not like it like "PERFECTION!", but it's another awesome one you need to watch if you're straying from any episode after "Pranks a Lot". 8.5/10
Not only my favorite season 5 episode, but my 2nd favorite of all-time. I LOVE this episode. It's very relate-able and captures the fear perfectly. There are so many classic moments it's hard to count. Hilarious and the best that post-movie has to offer imo.
Really good episode (for sure in my top 10 in that season) but not as good as my fav one ''New Digs'' , still enjoyed it though with good lines and funny moments (like Patrick trying to get that picture) and the ending was funny too...and fun 10/10