I used to dislike "Fools in April".
It's weird to think back on that, to be honest, because I love it so much now. The main reason I used to dislike this episode is because I felt it was way too mean-spirited. And yeah, Squidward is mean-spirited here, but frankly it's not as bad as it could've been, and he gets his due (AKA the townspeople shunning him, and him getting pranked hard in the end). I also used to get mad (well, mad is a strong word, but you get the vibes) at how weird and abrupt the ending was, but like...that's the whole point. I'll get back to that in a minute.
Like SpongeBob, I'm an April Fools aficionado. I change my social media profiles for April Fools, I try to act differently than I normally do, and I do try to pull some harmless pranks. SpongeBob in this episode is so cute with his enthusiasm for the holiday, and the fact that it's his favorite holiday is even cuter to me. Seriously, season 1 knocked it out of the park with how cute SpongeBob is, something that was kind of left by the wayside until season 10 or 11.
Anyway, like the topic of the episode implies, "Fools in April" is a pretty funny episode. At the very least, it's thoroughly entertaining. Squidward trying to apologize is hilarious, and I love that they stuck a...donkey...joke in there, if you know what I mean. Squidward's prank is hard to watch, but the writers toe the line excellently between making the audience uncomfortable on purpose, but not too uncomfortable. It doesn't last too long, and we cut away from the horrible prank multiple times to see Squidward's reactions, which provide some levity.
This episode also uses an aspect to SpongeBob I can't remember being revisited until "SpongeBob Meets The Strangler", which is that SpongeBob can be pretty smart sometimes, and he'll use those smarts to be a huge troll. I mean think about it, if, as I interpret it, his reaction was fake and he was really impressed by Squidward's prank, then it seems to me like SpongeBob planned his prank revenge right then and there, when he cried and ran out of the Krusty Krab. Like that's...that's brilliant. And I love it. Also, I think it's so fun how this episode can be interpreted in different ways (whether SpongeBob was legitimately upset or not, and if the ending has any meaning whatsoever), that isn't something you usually see in a show like SpongeBob SquarePants. I'm glad that episodes like these aren't too common, because then it would start to impact the comedy and simple nature of the show.
Anyway, every character is good in this episode. Like I said before, SpongeBob is adorable and I like the first segment of the episode with him pulling pranks. Mr. Krabs is only in this episode briefly, but I love how he gets in on the joke with SpongeBob when Squidward is originally pranked. It's that parental figure relationship, I tell you. Squidward is also good in this episode, even if he is a huge jerk, because he comes to regret it and then fumbles trying to apologize for a good few minutes. Patrick also is hilarious support, chewing the wire and frankly reminding Squidward that he's a jerkwad.
Now, about that ending. Yes, it's extremely random and abrupt. And that's perfect! Firstly, I think it fits an episode about April Fools, a holiday that's all about jokes and pranks and randomness. And like I was talking about before, in my interpretation this whole thing is an elaborate make-up prank against Squidward (I mean, that part is basically given, the real debate is when SpongeBob started his revenge prank). And then Squidward losing his mind is just perfect, some great voice acting as per usual.
Episode Tier: Amazing
Episode Score: 9/10