Oh god. This episode is just creepy! Spongebob falls in love with a Krabby Patty and treats it like a real girlfriend! And it just gets worse when you realize that this seems to base itself on people who are so depressed and lonely that they make their own "friends" out of inanimate objects!!!
1/10 (if it had not been for some funny moments, as well as the ending, this mess would've gotten a 0)
You know, many people say that Good Neighbors was the fall of Spongebob and it has never redeemed, but in my opinion, THIS is where Spongebob started slipping, without notice after 5 perfect episodes aired. It didn't reach the lower intestine until Atlantis SquarePantis, though. And I just can't talk about this episode without being grossed out.
This episode is gross. It makes me wanna throw up. I almost threw up. SpongeBob falling in love with a Krabby Patty is just a stupid idea. SpongeBob doesn't want to play with Patrick and karate with Sandy? How he leave them alone? Just because of his love for a Krabby Patty in this episode. I hate this episode so much and it is my least favorite Season 5 episode.
If any episode can be called So Bad It's Good, it's this one. I think the concept is baffling in a WTF funny way, and because of that, it's really ....interesting to see it played it. It feels like a parody of an episode, instead of a real thing that exists. There are some actually decent jokes here and there, and honestly, the song isn't that bad until the...scallop thing. On top of the weird-ness, the episode can't decided what the point is, or who's in the right or wrong here. Really, the only thing holding it back for me is the gross out factor, otherwise it's hilariously awful. There's no rating that exists that can fit this episode, so I'll leave now.
I love this episode. It's so bad it's good. I would give it a 10/10 for being so terrible it's amazing, but I would also give it a 0/10 for being disgusting and stupid. The median of 0 and 10 is 5. So yeah, 5/10