Pinned thread Unpopular Opinions you Have on SpongeBob

[SlipperytheTotodile]

Best Day Ever is really underhated i think that its a really good episode i mean that i really like that episode i like the jokes and the ending was happy too bad nick overhyped it causing its negative reception

 

[Season 4-11]

Many of these will be controversial, but I have plenty of them that I've developed over the years since I've last used this thread.

- Season 13 is the worst season of the whole show
- The best art styles the show has ever had were Seasons 4 and 9B
- Sponge On the Run is a bad movie
- Season 9B holds up with the pre-movie seasons (and season 4 imo)
- The Hankering is actually a decently good episode, and it's one of my favorites of Season 12 (which I also don't think is great tbf)
- Goodbye Krabby Patty would make a great series finale
- The My Leg episode ruined the running gag and it's not funny anymore
- Season 1 is overrated with many episodes being a low-tier "good" imo which isn't a lot compared to Seasons 2 - 4
- The SpongeBob Musical is honestly not that good
- I would rather watch Pet Sitter Pat, Yours, Mine & Mine, Demolition Doofus, and One Coarse Meal than most of Season 13

 

[MattTheSpongeFanatic]

Many of these will be controversial, but I have plenty of them that I've developed over the years since I've last used this thread.

- Season 13 is the worst season of the whole show
- The best art styles the show has ever had were Seasons 4 and 9B
- Sponge On the Run is a bad movie
- Season 9B holds up with the pre-movie seasons (and season 4 imo)
- The Hankering is actually a decently good episode, and it's one of my favorites of Season 12 (which I also don't think is great tbf)
- Goodbye Krabby Patty would make a great series finale
- The My Leg episode ruined the running gag and it's not funny anymore
- Season 1 is overrated with many episodes being a low-tier "good" imo which isn't a lot compared to Seasons 2 - 4
- The SpongeBob Musical is honestly not that good
- I would rather watch Pet Sitter Pat, Yours, Mine & Mine, Demolition Doofus, and One Coarse Meal than most of Season 13

I agree with pretty much EVERYTHING on here, except personally I think Season 13 is just meh. But yes, GKP would make a great series finale, and I agree with your other opinions here as well.

 

[SlipperytheTotodile]

Krusty Koncessionaires > Sb's Big Birthday Blowout

 

[Combusto82]

I don't like Larry the Lobster because of the very worst, disturbing and awful episode - Pet or Pests

He even doesn't remember SpongeBob even though they both are friends in other episodes! and yes, the horrible part where Larry almost ate the worm babies! WTF!

 

[SlipperytheTotodile]

Krabby Land > Dumped

I think Dream Hoppers is bad

 

[Rockoman123]

Modern Spongebob isn't terrible, you've just grown older and out of the target demographic of the show

 

[Yoshi]

Cheekbob fits SpongeBob more than normal cheeks

Many of these will be controversial, but I have plenty of them that I've developed over the years since I've last used this thread.

- Season 13 is the worst season of the whole show Disagree
- The best art styles the show has ever had were Seasons 4 and 9B Disagree
- Sponge On the Run is a bad movie Disagree
- Season 9B holds up with the pre-movie seasons (and season 4 imo) Agree
- The Hankering is actually a decently good episode, and it's one of my favorites of Season 12 Agree (which I also don't think is great tbf) Disagree
- Goodbye Krabby Patty would make a great series finale Agree
- The My Leg episode ruined the running gag and it's not funny anymore Disagree
- Season 1 is overrated with many episodes being a low-tier "good" imo which isn't a lot compared to Seasons 2 - 4 Disagree
- The SpongeBob Musical is honestly not that good Disagree
- I would rather watch Pet Sitter Pat, Yours, Mine & Mine, Demolition Doofus, and One Coarse Meal than most of Season 13 Disagree, although all those are good

 

[Robot-Android-Cyborg]

I've honestly stopped caring about any new Spongebob episodes, spin-offs, or whatever since Stephen Hillenburg died. It might be good, it might be bad, but I'm not going out of my way for it. Maybe that will change someday, but for the time being I've just stopped caring. I still have the same love for the older seasons and movies, and I will continue to.

-The best art styles the show has ever had were Seasons 4 and 9B

Season 4 has a radically different artsyle (and style/tone in general) than anything that came before or after. I don't think 5-9 is the best artsyle, it's too "stiff" looking I guess. But I must admit I like it better than the overly expressive new style.

- The My Leg episode ruined the running gag and it's not funny anymore

Agree.

- Season 1 is overrated with many episodes being a low-tier "good" imo which isn't a lot compared to Seasons 2 - 4

Slightly agree

 

[DannyWapbang]

Pearl is not a whiny spoiled brat. Pearl has been my favourite character ever since childhood, and while I may act like Sandy now, I headcanon Pearl to like the same things that I do, and she's never stopped being my favourite.

 

[Awe]

Season 1 is better than season 3

 

[Heyo_Heyo]

Season 1 is better than season 3

season 1 is boring

 

[TheCrunchyPudding00]

Spongehenge is actually a pretty good episode. It's a good example of the writers stepping out of the box. If it was part of the Legends of Bikini Bottom people would tolerate it much more.

 

[MattTheSpongeFanatic]

Spongehenge is actually a pretty good episode. It's a good example of the writers stepping out of the box. If it was part of the Legends of Bikini Bottom people would tolerate it much more.

SpongeHenge and Trenchbillies should be swapped, that would make more sense...

 

[Heyo_Heyo]

Spongehenge is actually a pretty good episode. It's a good example of the writers stepping out of the box. If it was part of the Legends of Bikini Bottom people would tolerate it much more.

I am sure people would hate it regardless the Legends Of Bikini Bottom episodes already aren’t liked that much except for The Bikini Bottom Triangle

 

[SlipperytheTotodile]

I actually thought Are you Happy Now and SJABB were meh episodes

 

[Mr. What Zit Tooya]

I actually thought Season 9A is better than Seasons 12-13

 

[PoliticalPatrick]

In my opinion Season 7 isn't that bad. I think it's comparable in quality to Season 8, with Seasons 11, 12 and 6 being a lot worse than both.

 

[Mr. What Zit Tooya]

In my opinion Season 7 isn't that bad. I think it's comparable in quality to Season 8, with Seasons 11, 12 and 6 being a lot worse than both.

I agree with Season 7, the second half is compared to Season 8, i only disagree with Season 11 which (in my opinion) is really good.

 

[PoliticalPatrick]

I agree with Season 7, the second half is compared to Season 8, I only disagree with Season 11 which (in my opinion) is really good.

I don't hate Season 11, but I just find it to be poorly written most of the time - even though the episode concepts and animations are really good across the board.