SBM is trash!

For your Treats! review:

Even though I like Gary's New Toy slightly better, I LOVE Treats very very much! It is possibly my 2nd favorite Season 8 episode, but yes, this episode is a perfect example of a good Gary episode. I thought the whole concept of saying "No" was great, Gary was really cute (and ACTUALLY pet-like for once), the twist ending with Gary actually responding to "No" was really nice, the fact that Patrick had the last Snail Bites in the world was hilarious, the montage with Gary doing cool things to get rewarded with Snail Bites was awesome, the commercial was enjoyable and NOT filler, and there are so many other things that make this episode great! :)

A funny episode. An excellent Gary episode. A nice moral (not the boring type.) And lots of fun bits and scenes here and there. All these things make this episode AMAZING!!! ^_^

Oh, and I liked this bit in your review when you wrote: "You have to No when to say know" Haha, lol. XD That's creative that you replaced the words like that!

Also, that's a shame that Selling Out and Mooncation are not on the list, but oh well. I do LOVE those episodes though.

And next is SpongeBob Meets the Strangler. :)

More_Spongebob_Sandy said:
Actually, Selling Out was cut from last-minute changes, but at the point, there won't be anything like that. I'm locking the list in place.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I did realize that when I went through the list. But it's okay. ^_^ I am glad that you are locking the list in place now, though. :)
 
More_Spongebob_Sandy said:
Okay, just for more conformation, the extended Band Geeks review was completely fake. However, I am actually bothered about the flag twirling scene, I mean in Nasty Patty we know the inspector's alive, and even fricking SWS doesn't have Squid killed (although having a full body cast), but come on, at least three fish were killed, all because of Squidward! But that's not a big deal. My main problem now is that the humor is really rushed. I mean, it's great material, but the timing is way off. I just couldn't manage to laugh at every single moment like Chocolate With Nuts, where the humor was so well timed it's in the top 3.

But the animation complaints, Squilliam complaints, song originality complaints, and "very character having a moment" complaints were ALL completely out of nowhere and was for the joke. But those two I mentioned are the main reasons why it's not on the list. (as well as over ration)


But let's forget about that now. It's over.
Click to expand...
I definitely realize that the extended review was fake. I also like that you crossed out some parts of it. :) And also, let me commend you for being the first person I've ever seen talk about that death scene. I've always wondered why they even decided to put that scene anyway. I never was really that bothered by it, but I still didn't really like it that much and never really found it that funny. But I can definitely understand why people would be bothered with it, because I'm pretty sure this is the only SpongeBob episode where someone LITERALLY dies! (Actually, Sandy's "twirly bird" died in Sandy's Rocket because of SpongeBob, in Krusty Love Mr. Puff died and turned into a lamp, and in the movie, many fish are seen dead (but still alive if exposed to water apparently) and SpongeBob and Patrick almost died. Neither of these were deaths were seen on-screen though. Also, Hooky and Nasty Patty (which I understand why you wouldn't be bothered by it, since the death was fake) has a somewhat strong theme of death in it. There are also a lot of death people (well, only as skeletons and zombies) seen in One Krabs' Trash.) ANYWAY, I think that it isn't right to put death in a kids' show. In my opinion, that scene wasn't really vulgar in any way, and it just showed people crashing into a blimp. It's still not a very good scene either way, since it's not really funny, it has death in it, and it wouldn't even have a significant impact on the episode if it wasn't there. To sum it all up, I hated how this scene had death, but I'm not too bothered by it because of how the scene was short and only supposed to be cartoony and comical. I am glad that someone FINALLY brought it up though. ^_^

For the pacing, I wasn't really too bothered by it either, but I can see what you mean by how it was too fast-paced and the episode's organization was kinda average. It was just joke after joke, instead of how Chocolate with Nuts was properly organized by slowing it down a bit and putting the jokes in between each scene, instead of making the joke the scene like Band Geeks did. So yes, Chocolate with Nuts was definitely better paced and organized than Band Geeks, which lacked in managing these aspects in a more proper way. (By the way, Chocolate with Nuts was definitely top 3 material, even though it's #9 for me.)

Yeah, those other complaints in the extended review definitely did seem like they came out of nowhere, lol. But I somehow did believe that you actually did think that way about the animation, Squilliam, song, and character moments. But yeah, those other 2 complaints definitely are understandable and agreeable, even though they bothered me slightly less than they did for you.

Yes, I definitely will forget about this and know that it's over. But the only reason I replied to it now is because I really wanted to reply about this when you first posted it, but I just wasn't able to. And I ALWAYS want to reply to what you have to say, even if it is too late to do so. So yeah, I'm glad that I was finally able to reply to this. ^_^
 
The death scene and Squidward saying "Too bad that didn't kill me" in Band Geeks didn't bother me at all. In fact these scenes were very funny because I love dark humor. Plus a lot cartoons do death scenes, Invader Zim made even an episode about killing someone (Bad, Bad Rubber Piggy).
 
"The Secret Box" is really underrated. Usually the first episode people tend to talk about a lot and praise is "Band Geeks" but I can see why you're probably not that big on it like other people are.
 
More_Spongebob_Sandy said:
4006884_700b.jpg
Click to expand...
Eew 9gagIs this artwork Canon or fanon? because I think it's fanmade.

Back to topic: Algae's Always Greener is a good episode, it provides a good "what-if" scenario, and the joke is kinda surreal too.
 
Bucket Sweet Bucket is a really good episode with a funny charcter dynamic between Plankton and SB, P, and SQ, and lots of really funny moments. I used to think it's overrated, but now I see what's so great about it! :)

Shell of a Man is an episode that I really love now. I used to think that it was gross, when I was a kid, but not anymore. It's really funny, especially during the navy reunion, when SpongeBob almost seems like ruining everything. And yes, Mr. Krabs didn't even mention money in this episode!!!!! :D We need more episodes where Mr. Krabs is like this, along with some money obsession episodes from time to time, but NOT ALL THE TIME! So yeah, I totally love this episode a lot more than I used to.

The Algae's Always Greener is an episode that I used to find Meh, because of how I thought it was kinda boring. But now I like it more, because the funny moments in this episode are indeed REALLY FUNNY, and the role-reversal theme works really well. I consider this episode Good now, and the only reason I don't consider this episode AMAZING is because of how it is a tad bit boring at times. And by the way, we really need more random gags like the soda gag in more episodes! Its randomness is hilarious!!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top