Dumped is correct!
We're already starting to get into episodes I like. Yes, I like one of the most hated pre movie episode, so sue me. But I just can't help but like it. The story is solid, and although the jokes are pretty meh, the story is great. So, Dumped is where Gary decides he likes Patrick better than Spongebob, and it's established kinda well after he has a sleepover with him. Spongebob feels heartbroken, and tries to find a new pet to rub it in their faces. Patrick honestly wasn't really a jerk, save for a few moments, and was more of the antagonist. Also, it's not his fault Gary wanted to be with him. Anyway, the jokes are kinda stale. Aside from a few decent gags, the jokes are pretty weak, and are mostly overshadowed due to the story. The Rex gag was honestly kinda boring, but Larry did manage to get a few laughs out of me. Eventually, Patrick goes to Spongebob's house to do some laundry there, and then SB breaks down crying in a heartwrenching scene. Yeah, I teared up a bit during this scene. Then it's revealed that Gary was only following Patrick because of the cookie, which did make me laugh. Yeah, so aside from stale jokes, this is honestly a not-that-bad episode.
Also, just a note: Ripped Pants is no longer a bad episode in my eyes. Rewatch made me realize I actually liked it, so please ignore my S1 rankings where I stated it as a bad episode.
Favorite Character: Spongebob
Favorite Moment: The cookie in the pocket.
Hint for #35: The fork was sexy, tbh.