Christmas Who? or It's A Spongebob Christmas?

[DiabolicalGenius]

I love Plankton, but Squidward's my second-favourite and even though the Jerktonium fruitcakes were... jerky, Squidward being like that and then dressing up like Santa and giving all of his stuff away is so sweet, especially after the way he treated SpongeBob, and then Santa laughing at the end and Squidward says he must be crazy and he faints is just so sweet... And The Very First Christmas is a great Christmas song too which I prefer to the one in IASBC.

 

[ThePineappleLord]

I feel that if the stop-motion In "its a sponge bob Christmas" was removed then it would have been a regular episode. And even though I liked it I have to go with "Christmas who?" because of squid ward's character development.

 

[Perry The Platypus]

Christmas who. I love IASC but CW has the sweet factor.

 

[todd phillips]

where is the both button? because they are both good one's.

 

[Kerststol]

I really like IASC. The animation is beautiful and it feels light-hearted. But, there's no beating Christmas Who?

 

[The Drifter]

Christmas Who obviously, I even learned about Christmas from that episode!

 

[Lightning McStorm]

Yep I was right I would be the only one to pick It's A SpongeBob Christmas.

 

[Master WhoBruh]

I love both of these episodes but I prefer Christmas Who over It's a SpongeBob Christmas like everybody else. That special is very heartwarming and even though Squidward is a jerk to SpongeBob sometimes, this episode, along with Dying for Pie, shows that Squidward has a heart. Plus, that special is way funnier than It's a SpongeBob Christmas IMO. I love It's a SpongeBob Christmas too but tbh, I'm not a fan of claymation in this episode and I thought the special is rushed.

 

[2000sKid]

CW, the plot is better, its funnier, and i dont like the animation for IASC