235a. Library Cards

EmployeeAMillion

Season 12 Time!
Joined
Feb 26, 2016
Messages
3,664
Likes
2,551
Location
Auckland, New Zealand
Despite the good message it teaches of “read a book, kids!”, I felt pretty uncomfortable at certain points. Should Patrick becoming smart really be a physical problem? I know it prevents him from heading outside and rehashing Patrick SmartPants, but I feel like this episode stays in the library so long that it gets stale.
 

Chris

Floridian
Joined
May 26, 2004
Messages
834
Likes
181
Location
Orlando Florida
EmployeeAMillion said:
Despite the good message it teaches of “read a book, kids!”, I felt pretty uncomfortable at certain points. Should Patrick becoming smart really be a physical problem? I know it prevents him from heading outside and rehashing Patrick SmartPants, but I feel like this episode stays in the library so long that it gets stale.
I don't like how they didn't actually get library cards in the episode.

It would have been cooler to me if they visited the Bikini Bottom Public Library or something.
 
Joined
Mar 16, 2010
Messages
832
Likes
725
Location
hell
Honestly, I feel like this episode just didn't need to exist. It felt like a mediocre retread of Patrick SmartPants, and Patrick was once again acting like a dumb ADHD child, which I'm a little surprised at since Mr. Lawrence wrote this one, and he did Patnocchio, which was far superior to this episode. Most of the episode is just bland visual humor, although there were a few scenes I genuinely enjoyed, like SpongeBob becoming a witch doctor. Otherwise, there really wasn't much for me to like in this episode. 4/10
 
Joined
Nov 10, 2017
Messages
1,376
Likes
350
Location
United States
Honestly the only thing that this had in common with Patrick SmartPants was the fact that Patrick was smart for part of it. But the rest of the time he was a braindead idiot, like always.
 

SpongeMountain

Imitation Krab
Joined
Apr 15, 2023
Messages
44
Likes
47
Although I find the episode funny, I think the message that is given in it seems very stereotyped.

I believe that knowledge can be acquired in any medium, be it television or a book. How do I say, it depends on the television content or it depends on the book that one reads, since I believe that there are several types of content in each one of them. This plot seems to me to follow the cliché of "TV is bad and books are good" which exhausts me a lot because some people have made too much emphasis on it.

Also, another thing that makes me not convinced is the fact that it is an HD version of the episode of season 4 that seemed much better written than this one; In addition, I felt Patrick much more realistic in that episode.

And be careful, I have nothing against making episodes with a similar theme, as long as it is also well built like its predecessor.
 
Last edited:

Pugs4Thugs

#1 SpongeBob Reviewer
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
2,081
Likes
1,471
Now, “Library Cards” is an episode that I have not seen very much at all. I’ve watched it at least twice, but I can’t remember a lot of it, aside from the basics of the plot, as per usual in situations like this. From what I can remember, this episode most closely reminds me of “Patrick SmartPants”. Let’s rewatch to see if this comparison still applies.

We start off with some mindless entertainment, and it makes sense that it’s so mindless because Patrick’s the one watching it. Though it is fun. Such a simple gag, yet it entertains me so. Patrick’s ready to watch some cartoons with SpongeBob, but he accosts the Bob (after a funny moment where he calls him “SpongeRobert”, literally that was out of nowhere and hilarious) as he is leaving a secret room. Or, it’s not a secret room, it’s actually SpongeBob’s library! I feel like we haven’t seen it in a while, and even then, the room rarely plays a central role in an episode like this.

We get a wonderful Gary appearance here, being the educated little snail that he is. But he is sadly bothered by Patrick’s mistreatment of the library. I love SpongeBob’s smug attitude here, it’s hilarious to me. He teaches Patrick that a library is a place to read books, something that Patrick knows nothing about. So, SpongeBob teaches Patrick the magic of books. Patrick’s stupidity here, while extreme, is quite endearing, so I have no problem with him apparently having no idea what books are. And his thirst for knowledge is something we rarely see nurtured in the star, so it makes the plot more interesting, at least on the outset.

Reading stimulates Patrick’s brain in a way it’s never been stimulated, and he starts to actually get smarter. He absorbs the words so fast that his head grows to insane proportions. And he starts talking all pretentious-like. So, so far, this episode is starting to become very similar to “Patrick SmartPants”. What remains to be seen is how annoying smart Patrick will become. Because in that episode, Patrick was endearing. Let’s see what this episode does. Well, Patrick certainly acts a bit more pretentious imo. But it’s not too bad. He gets his head stuck in the door when SpongeBob tries to take him out for ice cream, and instead of actually being useful he just spouts off a bunch of ridiculous technobabble in his proposal for getting his head out the door. See, truly smart people know how to convey ideas in a useful manner lol.

SpongeBob attempts to follow Patrick’s instructions, but he ends up accidentally splitting Gary up into a ton of tiny versions of himself. Way to give me a heart attack, episode. But, Gary’s presence does give SpongeBob an idea…use slime to get Patrick out of the door! After this fails, SpongeBob manages to find a book called “Head Shrinking For Beginners”…how convenient! And then we proceed to get a segment that was completely unexpected and earned some startled laughter outta me. And again, this fails. So, Patrick comes up with a new idea—he’s gotta get dumb in order to get free. And so we’ve got the return of a little mindless cartoon, and it works! Nothing much else for me to say after that.

“Library Cards” does remind me of “Patrick SmartPants”, and the episodes for sure have got some similarities. But we’re definitely not at the level of rip-off. I’ll just say that I liked this episode…less than that one. It stopped being interesting about 4 or 5 minutes in. And after that, the direction the episode was going to go in was quite predictable. I don’t mind predictability, but I do mind it when the easy-to-see path is dull.

Episode Tier: Okay
Episode Score:
6.8/10
 
Back
Top