#8 - Good Neighbors
Writers: Mike Bell
SBmania Score: 4.3
Season: 4
Good Neighbors was the first episode that I remember watching and thinking "huh... I didn't like that one." That was a weird feeling because I felt like it was Spongebob, and I was SUPPOSED to like what I was watching. I mean, I liked everything I had watched before, so why not like this episode? Well, now I realize that this episode is actually pretty terrible and I had very good reason to dislike it.
Let's start with the premise: Spongebob and Patrick annoy Squidward on his day off. In a pre-movie episode like this, Squidward would have done something that made the actions of Spongebob and Patrick justified in this episode. Here, they are annoying Squidward for no reason whatsoever, and it comes off as annoying and PAINFUL to watch, which is just what this episode is. Squidward is getting tormented at every minute for... no reason. In a pre-movie episode like "Squid's Day Off" or "Club Spongebob", Squidward did something to DESERVE this torment. Here, it just makes no sense.
Some people think that this episode is where the show got worse. I disagree, the show got worse with "Night Light," but this is definitely the first cringe-worthy episode of the show, and I feel like it should be more infamous than it is for being the first "Squidward Torture Episode."
Eventually, this episode just gets confused and Squidward develops a security system, which basically brings his house alive and goes about to destroy the town. Did this need to happen? Well... no. It was pointless, felt like filler, and only existed to give Squidward one last insult at the end of the episode. God, do I hate this one. I saw the downfall of the show coming from a mile away, and this was the first warning sign to me.