Pinned thread Season 5 Discussion

Joined
Aug 24, 2013
Messages
11,260
Location
Hell
Friend or Foe - A

The Original Fry Cook - B

Night Light - B+

Rise and Shine - B+

Waiting - C

Fungus Among Us - D+

Spy Buddies - A+

Boat Smarts - A

Good ol Whatshisname - D

New Digs - A+

Krabs a La Mode - A+

Roller Cowards - A+

Bucket Sweet Bucket - A

To Love a Patty - F

Breath of Fresh Squidward - B

Money Talks - B+

SpongeBob vs. the Patty Gadget - A

Slimy Dancing - B-

The Krusty Sponge - B+

Sing a Song of Patrick - A-

A Flea in Her Dome - B+

Goo Goo Gas - A+

Le Big Switch - B+

The Donut of Shame - B+

The Krusty Plate - A-

Atlantis SquarePantis - B-

Picture Day - B-

Pat No Pay - B+

Blackjack - B

Blackened Sponge - A-

Mermaid Man vs. SpongeBob - B-

The Inmates of Summer - B+

To Save a Squirrel - C

Pest of the West - B+

20,000 Patties Under the Sea - A

The Battle of Bikini Bottom - D-

Whatever Happened To SpongeBob? - C

The Two Faces of Squidward - A+

SpongeHenge - B+

Banned in Bikini Bottom - B-

Stanley S. SquarePants - A-


6 excellent episodes

9 great episodes

14 good episodes

8 meh episodes

3 bad episodes

1 horrible episode

This season has really grown on me. It's so darn good with such excellent episodes and so many good ones. Yeah, it has forgottable episodes but even bad ones aren't that so much.

I gave this season a "B"
 

Supmandude

Moby Dollar
Joined
Aug 7, 2010
Messages
4,472
Possibly the most overrated season ever. It's not horrible or anything, but compared to every other season, this is not very great at all.
 

Pinhead Larry

The Fountain of Squidward
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
1,607
Location
The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern I
Friend or Foe - Amazing
The Original Fry Cook - Bad
Night Light - Decent
Rise and Shine - Great
Waiting - Awful
Fungus Among Us - Awful
Spy Buddies - Meh
Boat Smarts - Meh
Good ol' Whatshisname - Awful
New Digs - Amazing
Krabs a la Mode - Amazing
Roller Cowards - Great
Bucket Sweet Bucket - Great
To Love A Patty - Awful
Breath of Fresh Squidward - Awful
Money Talks - Decent
Patty Gadget - Great
Slimy Dancing - Decent
Krusty Sponge - Bad
Sing a Song of Patrick - Amazing
A Flea In Her Dome - Bad
Donut of Shame - Great
Krusty Plate - Decent
Goo Goo Gas - Decent
Le Big Switch - Weak
Atlantis Squarepantis - Bad
Picture Day - Weak
Pat No Pay - Decent
Blackjack - Great
Blackened Sponge - Meh
Mermaidman vs SpongeBob - Meh
Inmates of Summer - Meh
To Save A Squirrel - Weak
Pest of the West - Meh
20k Patties Under The Sea - Great
Battle of Bikini Bottom - Bad
Whatever Happened To SpongeBob - Weak
Two Faces of Squidward - Great
Spongehenge - Weak
Banned In Bikini Bottom - Awful
Stanley S Squarepants - Decent

4 Amazing Episodes

8 Great Episodes

7 Decent Episodes

6 Meh Episodes

5 Weak Episodes

5 Bad Episodes

6 Awful Episodes

6th Best Season
 
Joined
Dec 30, 2015
Messages
668
Location
United States
My thoughts:

Friend Or Foe - Amazing
The Original Fry Cook - Good
Night Light - Meh
Rise and Shine - Ok
Waiting - Mediocre
Fungus Among Us - Bad
Spy Buddies - Great
Boat Smarts - Mediocre
Good Ol' Whatshisname - Meh
New Digs - Great
Krab á La Mode - Amazing ::dolphin noise:: YES!
Roller Cowards - Amazing
Bucket Sweet Bucket - Good
To Love a Patty - Terrible (WHY!?)
Breath of Fresh Squidward - Meh
Money Talks - Good
SpongeBob Vs. The Patty Gadget - Great
Slimy Dancing - Ok
The Krusty Sponge - Ok
Sing a Song of Patrick - Amazing
A Flea in Her Dome - Meh
The Donut of Shame - Great
The Krusty Plate - Great
Goo Goo Gas - Great
Le Big Switch - Good
Atlantis SquarePantis - Meh
Picture Day - Good
Pat No Pay - Meh
BlackJack - Ok
Blackened Sponge - Good
Mermaid Man Vs. SpongeBob - Good
The Inmates of Summer - Good
To Save a Squirrel - Meh
Pest of the West - Good
20,000 Patties Under the Sea - Good
The Battle of Bikini Bottom - Ok
WhoBob WhatPants - Meh
The Two Faces of Squidward - Great
SpongeHenge - Mediocre
Banned in Bikini Bottom - Meh
Stanley S. SquarePants - Meh

1 Terrible
1 Bad
3 Mediocre
10 Meh
5 Ok
10 Good
7 Great
4 Amazing

Ok Season
 

Alex Squarepants

angrier than ever
Joined
Dec 24, 2015
Messages
2,687
Location
dead
Friend or Foe - 10/10
The Original Fry Cook - 8.5/10
Night Light - 3.5/10
Rise and Shine - 5/10
Waiting - 2.5/10
Fungus Among Us - 3/10
Spy Buddies - 7.5/10
Boat Smarts - 8/10
Good ol' Whatshisname - 8/10
New Digs - 8/10
Krabs a la Mode - 9.5/10
Roller Cowards - 10/10
Bucket Sweet Bucket - 8.5/10
To Love A Patty - 1.5/10
Breath of Fresh Squidward - 2/10
Money Talks - 6.5/10
SB vs The Patty Gadget - 9.5/10
Slimy Dancing - 5/10
Krusty Sponge - 7.5/10
Sing a Song of Patrick - 9/10
A Flea In Her Dome - 3/10
Donut of Shame - 8.5/10
Krusty Plate - 8.5/10
Goo Goo Gas - 8.5/10
Le Big Switch - 6/10
Atlantis Squarepantis - 4/10
Picture Day - 7.5/10
Pat No Pay - 4/10
Blackjack - 7/10
Blackened Sponge - 4/10
Mermaidman vs SpongeBob - 8/10
Inmates of Summer - 8.5/10
To Save A Squirrel - 8/10
Pest of the West - 6/10
20k Patties Under The Sea - 7.5/10
Battle of Bikini Bottom - 8.5/10
Whatever Happened To SpongeBob - 2.5/10
Two Faces of Squidward - 8.5/10
Spongehenge - 6/10
Banned In Bikini Bottom - 7/10
Stanley S Squarepants - 2.5/10
 

CakeCup

Facing the BSOD
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
5,877
Location
In a vat full of eggplants
CakeCup posts her thoughts here.
Friend or Foe: Great
The Original Fry Cook: Great

Night Light: Okay
Rise and Shine: Good
Waiting: Bad
Fungus Among Us: Awful
Spy Buddies: Excellent
Boat Smarts: Bad
Good ol'Whatshisname: Okay
New Digs: Great
Krabs à la mode: Excellent
Roller Cowards: Excellent

Bucket Sweet Bucket: Great
To Love a Patty: Bad
Breath of Fresh Squidward: Meh
Money Talks: Great
SB vs. The Patty Gadget: Excellent
Slimy Dancing: Okay
The Krusty Sponge: Great
Sing a Song of Patrick: Great

A Flea in her Dome: Okay
The Donut of Shame: Great
The Krusty Plate: Good
Goo Goo Gas: Great
Le Big Switch: Good
Atlantis Squarepantis: Okay
Picture Day: Good
Pat No Pay: Bad
BlackJack: Meh
Blackened Sponge: Good
MM vs. SB: Good
The Inmates of Summer: Good

To Save a Squirrel: Meh
Pest of the West: Great
20,000 Patties Under the Sea: Good
Battle of Bikini Bottom: Great
WhoBob Whatpants: Bad
The Two Faces of Squidward: Great
Spongehenge: Meh
Banned in Bikini Bottom: Okay
Stanley S. Squarepants: Meh

Good season. Despite the bad episodes being way more frequent than S4, still like this season. Personally, I prefer the 1st half of S5 despite the bad episodes. The good episodes here range from just being decent to being really good and close to great. The ratings were all over the place, ranging from awful to excellent, and I have a number of guilty pleasures in the season.
 

Honest Slug

Ink Lemonade hurts me.
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
4,254
Location
Washington
Honest Slug reporting in

Friend or Foe - (A+)
The Original Fry Cook - (A-)
Night Light - (C+)
Rise and Shine - (B-)
Waiting - (D+)
Fungus Among Us - (D)
Spy Buddies - (A+)
Boat Smarts - (B+)
Good Ol' Whatshisname - (C-)
New Digs - (B+)
Krabs a La Mode - (A+)
Roller Cowards - (A+)
Bucket Sweet Bucket - (B)
To Love a Patty - (F)
Breath of Fresh Squidward - (B-)
Money Talks - (B)
SpongeBob vs. The Patty Gadget - (A-)
Slimy Dancing - (B+)
The Krusty Sponge - (A-)
Sing a Song of Patrick - (A+)
A Flea in Her Dome - (C)
The Donut of Shame - (A-)
The Krusty Plate - (B+)
Goo Goo Gas - (A-)
Le Big Switch - (B)
Atlantis SquarePantis - (F-)
Picture Day - (B+)
Pat No Pay - (C)
BlackJack - (B)
Blackend Sponge - (A)
Mermaid Man vs. SpongeBob - (A-)
The Inmates of Summer - (A)
To Save a Squirrel - (B)
Pest of the West - (B-)
20,000 Patties Under the Sea - (B)
The Battle of Bikini Bottom - (A)
What Ever Happend to SpongeBob? - (D-)
The Two Faces of Squidward - (A-)
SpongeHenge - (D+)
Banned in Bikini Bottom - (C-)
Stanley S. SquarePants - (C-)

Season 5: (B)

Despite the bad episodes being more frequent and worse, the good episodes are REALLY good and extremely creative. I also love the idea of triplet episodes and hope they come back.

Top 5
1. Roller Cowards
2. Sing a Song of Patrick
3. Spy Buddies
4. Krabs a la Mode
5. Friend or Foe?

Bottom 5
1. Atlantis SquarePantis
2. To Love a Patty
3. What Ever Happend to SpongeBob?
4. Fungus Among Us
5. Waiting

(A+) 5
(A) 3
(A-) 7
(B+) 5
(B) 6
(B-) 3
(C+) 1
(C) 2
(C-) 3
(D+) 2
(D) 1
(D-) 1
(F) 1
(F-) 1
 

Baloo

I GAVE YOU A JOB!
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
1,495
Location
The Mexican Jewish Cultural Festival
Friend or Foe? - Good
The Original Fry Cook - Good
Night Light - Bad
Rise and Shine - Meh
Waiting - Bad
Fungus Among Us - Bad
Spy Buddies - Good
Boat Smarts - Good (Guilty pleasure)
Good Ol' Whatshisname - Good (Guilty pleasure)
New Digs - Good
Krabs a La Mode - Good
Roller Cowards - Good
Bucket Sweet Bucket - Good
To Love a Patty - Bad
Breath of Fresh Squidward - Meh
Money Talks - Good
Spongebob VS the Patty Gadget - Good
Slimy Dancing - Good
The Krusty Sponge - Good
Sing a Song of Patrick - Good
A Flea in Her Dome - Bad
The Donut of Shame - Good
The Krusty Plate - Good
Goo Goo Gas - Good
Le Big Switch - Meh
Atlantis Squarepantis - Bad
Picture Day - Good
Pat No Pay - Meh
Blackjack - Meh
Blackened Sponge - Good
Mermaidman VS Spongebob - Good
The Inmates of Summer - Bad
To Save a Squirrel - Good
Pest of the West - Meh
20,000 Patties Under the Sea - Bad
The Battle of Bikini Bottom - Good
What Ever Happened to Spongebob? - Bad
The Two Faces of Squidward - Good
Spongehenge - Meh
Banned in Bikini Bottom - Bad
Stanley S. Squarepants - Bad

Meh Season
(Overall, this season is a mixed bag for me. There are a good amount of good episodes, but there is also a good amount of bad episodes, with some mehs in between. I would say that the good overall beats the bad, but there are too many mehs and bads for me to call this season good.)
 

Pinhead Larry

The Fountain of Squidward
Joined
Dec 22, 2011
Messages
1,607
Location
The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern I
Notables

Best: Krabs a la Mode
Runners Up: New Digs, Friend or Foe, Sing a Song of Patrick
Worst: Good ol' Whatshisname
Runners Up: Breath of Fresh Squidward, Waiting, Banned In Bikini Bottom
Guilty Pleasure: 20,000 Patties Under The Sea, Rise and Shine
Underrated Gems: Night Light, Bucket Sweet Bucket, Rise and Shine
Overrated: The Original Fry Cook, The Battle of Bikini Bottom
Overhated: Night Light, Stanley S Squarepants
Most Forgettable: Le Big Switch, Boat Smarts
 

PinkPearl

insert title here
Joined
May 28, 2007
Messages
3,893
Location
Wonderland
I feel like this would be a really interesting season to rank because I feel like a lot of the episodes are either really good or really terrible with little middle ground. Again, I shall use the Pieguy method with my top three in the Top Tier category.

Top Tier
Krabs a la Mode
Roller Cowards
The Krusty Sponge

Good
Friend or Foe
The Original Fry Cook
Spy Buddies
New Digs
Bucket Sweet Bucket
Breath of Fresh Squidward
Spongebob vs. the Patty Gadget
Picture Day (I like this one more than I thought I did)
The Inmates of Summer
The Battle of Bikini Bottom
The Two Faces of Squidward

Meh
Night Light
Waiting
Boat Smarts
Good Ol' Whathisname
Money Talks
Sing a Song of Patrick
Blackjack
Blackened Sponge
Pest of the West

ScumBob
Rise and Shine (sorry, Patrick, not your best performance)
Fungus Among Us
To Love a Patty (yet, I will still watch it when it comes on...)
Slimy Dancing
A Flea in Her Dome
The Donut of Shame
The Krusty Plate (just didn't care for this one)
Atlantis SquarePantis
Pat No Pay
To Save a Squirrel
20,000 Patties Under the Sea (I'm not even sure why, but I just didn't like this one)
Whatever Happened to Spongebob?
SpongeHenge
Banned in Bikini Bottom
Stanley S. SquarePants

With 14 total good episodes, 9 meh episodes, and 15 ScumBob episodes, it was actually a pretty tight match.
 

CakeCup

Facing the BSOD
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
5,877
Location
In a vat full of eggplants
Top 5 of the season
5: Sing a Song of Patrick
4: Spy Buddies
3: Spongebob vs. The Patty Gadget
2: Roller Cowards
1: Krabs a la Mode

Roller Cowards and Krabs a la Mode were so close, they can be interchangable

Bottom 5 of the season
5: Whatever Happened to Spongebob
4: Boat Smarts
3: Waiting
2: To Love a Patty
1: Fungus Among Us

This season is a 7.3/10. Still good, but not as good as seasons 1-4. The good episodes, especially the top 5, were REALLY GOOD.

In comparison...
Season 1: 8.6/10 (Great)
Season 2: 9.2/10 (Excellent)
Season 3: 9.1/10 (Excellent)
Season 4: 7.6/10 (Good)
 

Honest Slug

Ink Lemonade hurts me.
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
4,254
Location
Washington
Notables

Best: Roller Cowards
Runners Up: Sing a Song of Patrick, Friend or Foe, Krabs a la Mode & Spy Buddies
Worst: Atlantis Squarepantis
Runners Up: To Love a Patty, Fungus Among Us, What Ever Happend to SpongeBob & Spongehenge
Guilty Pleasure: Boat Smarts & To Save a Squirrel
Underrated Gems: Bucket Sweet Bucket, Slimy Dancing, Blackend Sponge, Mermaid Man vs. SpongeBob & The Battle of Bikini Bottom
Overrated: The Two Faces of Squidward
Overhated: Night Light & A Flea in Her Dome
Most Forgettable: To Save a Squirrel, Banned in Bikini Bottom & Stanley S. SquarePants

I liked this season a lot more than most.
 

Jack M Crazyfish

I'm back, I guess.
Joined
Jun 5, 2016
Messages
878
Location
United Kingdom
Here's my List

Friend or Foe? - Great
The Original Fry Cook - Good
Night Light - Mediocre
Rise and Shine - Mediocre
Waiting - Awful
Fungus Among Us - Terrible
Spy Buddies - Amazing
Boat Smarts - Bad
Good ol' Whatshisname - Meh
New Digs - Amazing
Krabs á la Mode - God-Tier
Roller Cowards - Amazing
Bucket Sweet Bucket - Good
To Love a Patty - Terrible
Breath of Fresh Squidward - Bad
Money Talks - Okay
SpongeBob vs. The Patty Gadget - Great
Slimy Dancing - Meh
The Krusty Sponge - Amazing
Sing a Song of Patrick - Great
A Flea in Her Dome - Awful
The Donut of Shame - Great
The Krusty Plate - Good
Goo Goo Gas - Good
Le Big Switch - Meh
Atlantis SquarePantis - Okay (Guilty Pleasure)
Picture Day - Great
Pat No Pay - Bad
BlackJack - Great
Blackened Sponge - Amazing
Mermaid Man vs. SpongeBob - Good
The Inmates of Summer - Great
To Save a Squirrel - Meh
Pest of the West - Bad
20,000 Patties Under the Sea - Great
The Battle of Bikini Bottom - Amazing
Whatever Happened to SpongeBob? - Bad
The Two Faces of Squidward - Good
SpongeHenge - Good (Guilty Pleasure)
Banned in Bikini Bottom - Bad
Stanley S. SquarePants - Bad

1 God-Tier Episode
6 Amazing Episodes
8 Great Episodes
7 Good Episodes
2 Okay Episodes
4 Meh Episodes
2 Mediocre Episodes
7 Bad Episodes
2 Awful Episodes
2 Terrible Episodes

Okay Season 6/10

Top 5 Episodes:
5- Spy Buddies
4- Blackened Sponge
3- New Digs
2- The Battle of Bikini Bottom
1- Krabs á la Mode

Bottom 5 Episodes:
5- Pest of the West
4- A Flea in Her Dome
3- Waiting
2- Fungus Among Us
1- To Love a Patty

Yeah this season was a step-down from season 4 but it was still decent and enjoyable to watch even if it included my least favourite episode of the show (To Love a Patty) that episode should burn in the deep-depths of hell but it also includes my favourite post-movie eppy (Krabs á la Mode) but you better get ready because now we're entering a new SpongeBob in season 6.
 

SquiddlyPie

random gal
Joined
Jul 9, 2014
Messages
1,199
Location
Greece
Let's continue with Season 5! As said before :
-Amazing (for episodes I love/really really like)
-Good (for episodes I really like/ or just like)
-Meh (for so so episodes or likeable a lil bit)
-Bad (for episodes I don't like/hate)
-Terrible (this is new -I didn't have it in the first 4 seasons review- but I think some episodes deserve this on there...)

Friend or Foe - Bad (yeah...I HATE this episode..I've hated it since I was little, I don't know why everyone seems to love it, it's really overrated)
The Original Fry Cook - Meh
Night Light - Good (not that good, just didn't want to give it the ''meh'' sign)
Rise and Shine - Meh
Waiting - Good
Fungus Among Us - Terrible (this episode is really bad guys)
Spy Buddies - Amazing (FINALLY, an amazing episode...this is definitely one of the best episodes of this season)
Boat Smarts - Bad (this episode is not good, it's so wrong in so many levels)
Good ol' Whatshisname - Good (I actually enjoyed that one..)
New Digs - Amazing (Episode 85 is definitely one of the best pairings because both episode are GREAT)
Krabs a la Mode - Amazing (same with New Digs)
Roller Cowards - Amazing
Bucket Sweet Bucket - Good
To Love A Patty - Terrible (I HATE IT WITH ALLLL MY SOUL, JUST WHY.. :( )
Breath of Fresh Squidward - Good (that's a guilty pleasure for me )
Money Talks - Good
SB Vs. The Patty Gadget - Amazing (one of my favourites of this season)
Slimy Dancing - Good
The Krusty Sponge - Good
Sing a Song of Patrick - Good
A Flea In Her Dome - Good
The Donut of Shame - Good
The Krusty Plate - Good
Goo Goo Gas - Amazing (also one of this season's gems)
Le Big Switch - Bad
Atlantis Squarepantis - Good
Picture Day - Good
Pat No Pay - Bad
Blackjack - Good
Blackened Sponge - Terrible (see what I wrote about this episode in it's thread...that's why I hate it)
Mermaidman vs SpongeBob - Good
Inmates of Summer - Meh
To Save A Squirrel - Good
Pest of the West - Meh
20.000 Patties Under The Sea - Good
Battle of Bikini Bottom - Meh
Whatever Happened To SpongeBob? - Amazing (I love this so much)
Two Faces of Squidward - Good
Spongehenge - Bad
Banned In Bikini Bottom - Good (close to meh)
Stanley S.Squarepants - Good
It's a good season as well even though we had lots of meh/bad/terrible episodes...some of them were brilliant so yeah..not as good as Season 1,2,3 and 4 though...
Total :
Season 1 : 0 Bad
Season 2 : 3 Bad
Season 3 : 3 Bad
Season 4 : 2 Bad
Season 5 : 8 Bad/Terrible (it didn't go really well)
 
Joined
Jan 8, 2016
Messages
16
Location
USA
Friend or Foe? - A+
The Original Fry Cook - A-
Night Light - C+
Rise and Shine - B-
Waiting - D-
Fungus Among Us - D+
Spy Buddies - A
Boat Smarts - C
Good Ol' Whatshisname - B
New Digs - A+
Krabs a la Mode - A+
Roller Cowards - A+
Bucket Sweet Bucket - B
To Love a Patty - F
Breath of Fresh Squidward - D+
Money Talks - B+
SpongeBob vs. The Patty Gadget - A+
Slimy Dancing - B-
The Krusty Sponge - A
Sing a Song of Patrick - A
A Flea in Her Dome - D+
The Donut of Shame - B+
The Krusty Plate - A-
Goo Goo Gas - A+
Le Big Switch - C+
Atlantis Squarepantis - F
Picture Day - A
Pat No Pay - C-
BlackJack - B
Blackend Sponge - A+
Mermaid Man vs. SpongeBob - B+
The Inmates of Summer - A-
To Save a Squirrel - C
Pest of the West - B-
20,000 Patties Under the Sea - B
The Battle of Bikini Bottom - A+
"What Ever Happened to SpongeBob?" - F
The Two Faces of Squidward - A+
Spongehenge - D
Banned in Bikini Bottom - B
Stanley S. SquarePants - C-

Well this season had mostly good episodes, some really good episodes, but also some of the worst episodes ever, a mixed bag for sure. I think it's a B-

Top 5
1. Krabs a la Mode
2. New Digs
3. The Two Faces of Squidward
4. Blackend Sponge
5. The Battle of Bikini Bottom

Bottom 5
1. "What Ever Happened to SpongeBob?"
2. To Love a Patty
3. Atlantis Squarepantis
4. Waiting
5. Spongehenge
 

Jack M Crazyfish

I'm back, I guess.
Joined
Jun 5, 2016
Messages
878
Location
United Kingdom
Bold and Brash said:
Friend or Foe? - A+
The Original Fry Cook - A-
Night Light - C+
Rise and Shine - B-
Waiting - D-
Fungus Among Us - D+
Spy Buddies - A
Boat Smarts - C
Good Ol' Whatshisname - B
New Digs - A+
Krabs a la Mode - A+
Roller Cowards - A+
Bucket Sweet Bucket - B
To Love a Patty - F
Breath of Fresh Squidward - D+
Money Talks - B+
SpongeBob vs. The Patty Gadget - A+
Slimy Dancing - B-
The Krusty Sponge - A
Sing a Song of Patrick - A
A Flea in Her Dome - D+
The Donut of Shame - B+
The Krusty Plate - A-
Goo Goo Gas - A+
Le Big Switch - C+
Atlantis Squarepantis - F
Picture Day - A
Pat No Pay - C-
BlackJack - B
Blackend Sponge - A+
Mermaid Man vs. SpongeBob - B+
The Inmates of Summer - A-
To Save a Squirrel - C
Pest of the West - B-
20,000 Patties Under the Sea - B
The Battle of Bikini Bottom - A+
"What Ever Happened to SpongeBob?" - F
The Two Faces of Squidward - A+
Spongehenge - D
Banned in Bikini Bottom - B
Stanley S. SquarePants - C-

Well this season had mostly good episodes, some really good episodes, but also some of the worst episodes ever, a mixed bag for sure. I think it's a B-

Top 5
1. Krabs a la Mode
2. New Digs
3. The Two Faces of Squidward
4. Blackend Sponge
5. The Battle of Bikini Bottom

Bottom 5
1. "What Ever Happened to SpongeBob?"
2. To Love a Patty
3. Atlantis Squarepantis
4. Waiting
5. Spongehenge
Your top 5 is almost identical to mine.

Anyway...
Best: Krabs á la Mode
Runners Up: The Battle of Bikini Bottom, New Digs and Blackened Sponge
Worst: To Love a Patty
Runners Up: Fungus Among Us, Waiting and A Flea in Her Dome
Guilty Pleasure: SpongeHenge, Good ol' Whatshisname
Underrated Gems: New Digs, Blackened Sponge and The Krusty Sponge
Overrated: Roller Cowards, Pest of the West, SB vs. The Patty Gadget and Banned in Bikini Bottom
Overhated: Atlantis SquarePantis, SpongeHenge
Most Forgettable: To Save a Squirrel, Le Big Switch
 
Top