Most Overrated/Underrated Season

[SpongyMaterial]

Overrated: season 2

Underrated: season 5, 6, and 7

 

[spongebobforever12]

Overrated 1 (possibly 1-3) but mostly 1
Underrated season 5 (and season 9) for hellenburg era fans

 

[Squidward1999]

Overrated: Season 3

Underrated: Season 5

 

[Awe]

Overrated: Season 11
Underrated: Season 5

 

[SpongeBox]

The most overrated for me is probably Season 2. Not that I don't like it. There's just at least a couple season I like a bit more.

I'll say Season 5 is the most underrated. In terms is reception, Season 5 is probably the most mixed. Still, it had some great episodes, and I like about as much as Season 4.

 

[Season 4-11]

Overrated: Season 3
Underrated: Season 8

 

[Emy]

Overrated: Idk
Underrated: Season 11

 

[MattTheSpongeFanatic]

Overrated: Season 3
Underrated: Season 7

 

[SlipperytheTotodile]

season 7

 

[Yoshi]

Top 3 Most Overrated Seasons
3. Season 1
2. Season 3
1. Season 2
Top 3 Most Underrated Seasons
3. Season 12
2. Season 6
1. Season 7

 

[Squidward1999]

Go figures with the first 3 seasons...

 

[Emy]

Overrated: Season 10
Underrated: Season 11

 

[Bigsmoker]

Overrated: Season 9 (still a good season but a bit overrated for me)
Underrated: Season 8

 

[Perfect Censorship!]

Overrated: Season 2 (I still love it though!)
Underrated: Season 4

 

[Neon2500]

Most overrated: 11 (not an option)
Most underrated: 6

 

[Mr. What Zit Tooya]

Overrated: Season 3 (I think this goes without saying)
Underrated: Season 5 and 9A

 

[ssj4gogita4]

Overrated: Season 5-8
Underrated: Season 1

 

[Heyo_Heyo]

Overrated: Season 3 (I think this goes without saying)
Underrated: Season 5 and 9A

awwww jealous of season 3's popularity