Most Overrated/Underrated Season

[Ol Bold and Brash]

Which season do you find the most Overrated/Underrated

 

[BobCarotte]

Most overrated: Season 2
Most underrated: Season 5

 

[spongie33]

Most overrated: Season 1
Most underrated: Season 8

 

[TheSpongeWhoCan'tFly]

Overrated: 1
Underrated: 5

 

[Fred Mercury]

S3 (over) and S6 (under)

 

[Honest Slug]

Overrated: Season 6
Underrated: Season 5

 

[CakeCup]

Overrated: 1
Underrated: 9

 

[MrTortellini00]

Overrated: 3 3 AND 3 AGAIN
Underrated: 5/8

 

[The Appetizer]

Overrated: 3
Underrated: 5

 

[Alex Squarepants]

Overrated: 3
Underrated: 9

 

[ryanator20x6]

Overrated: 9 (It's okay, but nowhere near the classics)
Underrated: 3 (I find it to be distinctly better than seasons 1 and 2, though I really like all three)

Season 8 is a runner up for underrated, it had some really good episodes.

 

[MrTortellini00]

Overrated: 9 (It's okay, but nowhere near the classics)
Underrated: 3 (I find it to be distinctly better than seasons 1 and 2, though I really like all three)

Season 8 is a runner up for underrated, it had some really good episodes.

This, from my experience, can't be anything but wrong.

 

[ryanator20x6]

This, from my experience, can't be anything but wrong.

Explain.

 

[MrTortellini00]

Explain.

I just can't see season 3 or even 2 being called underrated, as those are the seasons that are the most acclaimed and apprecated ones of the show. It just... doesn't look right to me, but it's okay if you think so.

 

[Invincibubble]

Overrated: Season 3
Underrated: Season 9

 

[ryanator20x6]

I just can't see season 3 or even 2 being called underrated, as those are the seasons that are the most acclaimed and apprecated ones of the show. It just... doesn't look right to me, but it's okay if you think so.

I'm specifically trying to say that I like Season 3 a lot better than Season 2. Most people on this site seem to like both of them equally.

 

[Taylor Swift]

Season 2 and Season 7.

 

[iedasb]

Most overrated: Season 1
Most underrated: Season 8
I like the episodes of Season 8, don't know why people don't like them much...

 

[Pinhead Larry]

Overrated: S1
Underrated: S6

 

[Ol Bold and Brash]

Overrated: S2 (but It's still my favorite season)
Underrated: S5

Spoiler

Underrated Runner-Ups: S4 and S8