216b. The Clam Whisperer

MasiHosseini

Krabby Patty Burglar
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
2,453
Likes
640
Location
Arnhem
Season: 11

Episode: The Clam Whisperer

This episode was kinda good. The plot was refreshing, because we didn't have many episodes about clams. There were some funny jokes. 7/10
 

Honest Slug

Ink Lemonade hurts me.
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
4,252
Likes
5,026
Location
Washington
I'm somewhat of a Ben Gruber sympathizer (I don't like his episodes but I think he isn't worse than the other season 10 writers) however I think I can agree with the consensus that this was a rather poor episode. The beginning is truly awful. It serves no purpose other than to have Patrick flail and whine like a baby and having Patrick still sleeping at the end was borderline self parody of how unneeded that farce was. The rest of the episode is nothing to ride home about either. Oh wow SpongeBob trying to tame nature, never have I seen this before! I'll give the episode credit for having a pretty funny gag of Mr. Krabs insulting the clams and having a somewhat fun (If meandering) segment of SpongeBob living like a clam. However even these good parts feel disconnected from the episode's many ideas. I wasn't annoyed by this episode in the same way Krusty Katering did but man I'm getting sick of these stock plotlines they keep relying on. At least House Worming had a fun little short. I can't really think of what The Clam Whisperer is adding to the table.

4/10
 

LadyElvis8

SpongeBob's wife
Joined
Jul 15, 2017
Messages
100
Likes
21
Location
California
The idea reminded me of Jellyfish Jam but with clams. Well, I didn't mind at all with this one because it's cute every time when Spongey attends to animals and gets so attached.*sigh* It reminds me of me.
 
Joined
Nov 10, 2017
Messages
1,376
Likes
350
Location
United States
On my first watch, I thought this episode was pretty decent. On my second watch, I realized this episode is just a complete mess. Really not much going on aside from the clams annoying everybody. There were a few good jokes, but that's about it. It's average.

THE LIST:
1. Cave Dwelling Sponge (B)
2. The Clam Whisperer (C)
 

Depressed Luigi

Dead Inspector
Joined
Jul 18, 2015
Messages
1,713
Likes
1,717
This episode felt a little too fast-paced, but it was still a good episode overall. I liked it for similar reasons as Cave-Dwelling Sponge, I liked seeing all the clams and what they did throughout the episode.
I'd say this is about as good as The Check-Up and Cave Dwelling Sponge, so a Good episode, maybe about a 8.5 or a 9.0? I like to watch new episodes a second time before deciding exactly where they are, since most episodes of any show feel a little better the second time to me for some reason. Also, this and Cave Dwelling Sponge were so similar that I just copy and pasted my Cave Dwelling Sponge response and changed the reasons why I liked it and a few other words
But it was barely even like Whelk Attack though...
Wintermelon43 said:
Nah, don't just change your opinion because one other person has a differant (and completatly overexaggerated) opinion. Everybody has differant opinions. Some people need to learn not to watch shows they hate. Believe me, This is nothing like Sportz. Sportz was nothing except people getting hurt, this and Cave Dwelling Sponge at least have much more than that.
Season 11 I feel like has been more like 9B than 10 so far imo. Some of the Season 11 episodes are still a little too fast-paced and zany, and could use some more jokes, but they're still good, none of them have been terrible or anything. And Spot Returns and The Check-Up weren't like Season 10 at all.
I hate my old self
 

SquiddlyPie

random gal
Joined
Jul 9, 2014
Messages
1,199
Likes
272
Location
Greece
This is so far my favorite (I have only watched this and Cave Dwelling Sponge from season 11). I think it was definitely funnier than it's sister which it tried but failed for me....I LOVED the scene with Mr. Krabs hatin on them clams to spit pearls on him, idk why but it really stood out to me as a joke or gag or whatever....the ending was funny and I liked it too....I also liked the fact that they were angry all the time but always calm to SpongeBob , it's a 9.5/10 from me.

So far :
1. The Clam Whisperer (9.5/10)
2. Cave Dwelling Sponge (8/10)
 

Tyler730

Part Computer or Something
Joined
Dec 20, 2017
Messages
63
Likes
20
Ugh, why did I like this episode? It’s annoying as hell and extremely boring! I rewatched this the other day and wowzas I didn’t think it was going to suck this much. I also believe its sister episode is poor but definitely better than this.
 

GlitchyGoomba

Bomb-Selling Pirate
Joined
Feb 14, 2022
Messages
155
Likes
17
Location
Inside an arcade machine
I think this episode is pretty dumb, the majority of it rehashes two particular season 1 episodes that feature jellyfish and doesn't really add anything new to the table. Also I hate the jokes.
 

Pugs4Thugs

#1 SpongeBob Reviewer
Joined
Apr 23, 2016
Messages
2,081
Likes
1,471
So remember how last review I was saying how I don’t remember some episodes of season 11 very well? Well, we’re at the first one now—”The Clam Whisperer”. I literally do not remember this episode one bit LMAO. I think I might know the general plot, but I’m halfway guessing. I’m sure it’s because I’ve seen this episode very few times. So I’m glad to have the opportunity to view it again.

“The Clam Whisperer” is about SpongeBob and…clams. As you might expect from the title. The beginning segment of this episode, with the clams migrating to warmer climates (with some neat visual gags in there), makes me wonder what direction this episode might take. Are we going “Rock A Bye Bivalve”? “Jellyfish Jam”? “Jellyfish Hunter”? “House Worming”? Or something entirely different? I’m hoping it won’t be “House Worming”, though I suppose it would provide this episode the opportunity to learn from the mistakes of that one. As it turns out, this episode reminds me most of “Sanctuary!” with a side of “SpongeHenge” and “Jellyfish Hunter”.

The conversation between SpongeBob and Patrick literally makes me go wide-eyed. I don’t know how else to describe it. Like you know that gif of the guy blinking? This one? Yeah, that’s me while watching this scene. Because Patrick just starts screaming for literally no reason, for a joke that is so…bizarre to me. And unnecessary. I don’t dislike it or anything, it’s just like…okay then. As the scene goes on, I realize something that isn’t working for me here is that it all feels like…padding. I don’t know, I hate using the terms filler and padding, because usually they’re misused and used way too much, but here I think it fits. Because the actual set up of the episode is being delayed by these dragging moments. And of course, this show is rarely ever plot-driven, hence why I think filler is a term that is rarely accurately used here, but I think this is one of those rare occasions that the term fits. While I’m watching, it’s just like “okay, I get it!” as Patrick continues to be dumb and quite exaggerated.

Finally, we get to looking at the clams. Lots of great visual gags here as we see all the different kinds of clams. SpongeBob wants to see the clams up close, so he lures them with food. Or…he tries to, but Patrick keeps eating it. And then Patrick falls asleep. I am again struck with the feeling that Patrick is completely unnecessary here. And I don’t just mean for the plot. Considering he’s not making me laugh, he’s unnecessary for the comedy too. But whatever, once he falls asleep, he exits the episode (kind of, he’s still a device even while sleeping). The clams crowd around Conch Street, which of course gets Squidward involved in things. It’s fun to see him do a different art for once—theatre. And everything involving him in this scene is hilarious.

SpongeBob goes to work, and the clams follow him in a scene that reminds me quite a bit of “Jellyfish Jam”. Very fun. The episode’s title really comes into play here as the clams seem to follow his every move. Eventually, they all arrive at the Krusty Krab, and the clams immediately start stealing Krabby Patties. SpongeBob tries to exact control over them, but it doesn’t work. I will say, this episode does a good job at making the clams fun to watch. I think the fact that there’s so many of them, and they move in sync, just makes them visually interesting right off the bat, which can help a lot in making a character (or multiple of them, in this case…though they are of course lumped into one general entity) fun to watch. It’s something “House Worming” somewhat failed to do, but that “Sanctuary!” did well.

The clams cause chaos at the Krusty Krab, and eventually Mr. Krabs gets involved, telling SpongeBob to get the clams out of the restaurant…at least until the clams start spitting pearls. This is where the “Jellyfish Hunter” parallels really come into play. Mr. Krabs purposefully aggravates them to get pearls, but unexpectedly, the episode does not spend any longer going in this direction, as SpongeBob takes the clams out of the Krusty Krab. The clams then cause more chaos as SpongeBob walks downtown. Lots of funny jokes and gags here. SpongeBob and the clams are then confronted by an angry, injured mob. I must say, I loved the joke with the violinist. Very clever.

SpongeBob leads the clams out of town, being quite the clam whisperer, and basically replicating “Nature Pants”, which was very surprising to me. SpongeBob’s clam design is hilarious, and I love it. After a whole season out in nature, the clams migrate away once more. So SpongeBob finally heads back home. And after Squidward had just gotten his house clean, he falls into the giant puddle of Patrick’s spit (as he was still sleeping). Squidward and Patrick then run off screaming hilariously, and SpongeBob goes to sleep in his giant nest. Good ending.

“The Clam Whisperer” started off pretty weak, but once the actual plot of the episode got going, it was really fun! So in that way, this episode is kinda like a hidden gem, as the first few minutes set an expectation, at least for me, that this episode was not gonna be very good. Because of those less than stellar first couple minutes, though, I have to refrain from putting this episode in my Amazing tier, despite the rest of it being worthy of that honor. A high Great seems good enough!

Episode Tier: Great
Episode Score:
8.9/10
 
Back
Top