This episode is really.....just....stupid. Before I state why I just want to say that why is Spongebob's voice in the beginning really weird? Anyway this episode involves both Spongebob and Patrick acting like hypocritical idiots, but mostly Patrick. He is borderline dumb here. And it's over ONE toy that Spongebob wanted to share. This episode has pretty funny gags that made me snicker a bit which is why I don't hate it a lot, but besides that, this episode is pointless and forgettable. This episode is also kind of a mix between Pat no Pay, Waiting, and a few other episodes. 3.5/10
EDIT: I hate this episode more now. The gags in this episode were actually pretty weak, and I don't think Spongebob is in the wrong here at all. 0/10
I say kind of, only because I did enjoy some of the jokes and moments, and I also noticed old soundtrack when SpongeBob was getting out of bed!
Other than those things, this episode is bad. The biggest thing, is Patrick being ridiculously out of character here. A big jerk for sure, and it just sets the mood down and distracts you from the episode. Nonetheless, the plot was still boring and didn't offer much either way.
I hate this episode ! I hate this season! Seriously guys how can you hate Season 6 more than this AWFUL season ? This season has everything bad!!! Though I hate this episode, I don't find it worse than A Pal For Gary because of Patrick's dance (the only good scene :P ) Patrick is being a jerk in the whole episode and as a member said it has a really bad message for the kids...where are the old episodes that used to have strong good messages for the kids??? This episode shouldn't exist...3/10 :/
In my eyes, it can be kinda funny, and though Patrick was a selfish jerk, this wasn't him at his worst. Patrick didn't cause any physical harm to anyone (though he did steal at the end, that's one thing that needs to be improved), and if anything, the fighting between SpongeBob and Patrick reflects a typical argument between siblings. Because let's face it, a lot of people with a sibling can probably relate to this episode
This episode is SOOOO BAD. First is possibly the WORST appearance of Patprick at his jerk side. Patprick here feels violated and destroyed. This episode is my 9th least favorite episode of all time (3rd in season 7). Not funny horrible ending. Hardly anything enjoyable. 1.5/10. Fun fact: a joke in the episode with SpongeBob using a milkshake license as an ID would eventually become a plotpoint to a later episode from season 9, "License to Milkshake" a way better episode.
I HAAAAAAAAAAAATE THIS FREAKING EPISODE !
I despise it and for 1 one reason
Patrick is such a jerk on this episode. At the end you'd think he would learn his lesson right? No
Patrick takes Spongebob's wallet and says "Have you learned nothing about sharing"
That part made grab a hammer and bang it across my head until I was unconscious
It's not as bad as the card and I don't hate it as much as I used to. Still bad, Patrick is intolerable and the story feels harsh. 3/10
Edit: Still far from a good episode but I find it very overhated, at least this episode attempts humor, something I can't say about many season 7 episodes. In fact once you get over Patrick it's got its moments.