I thought that this episode wasn't terrible, but it lacked a lot. The plot didn't really make any sense: Why would Plankton start a band in hope of getting the formula? And there were two booger jokes that I didn't find funny. All in all, not the worst of season 6 but a pretty weak season premiere. 5.8/10
The best Season 6 episode, in my opinion. While not being too good, it still got a few chuckles out of me, and didn't rely on being completely gross, or completely flanderized to make its point. Which, at that point, I could appreciate.
This was another fantastic episode. Even better than it's partner, another fantastic episode. The gags here were amazing. There also wasn't the mean spirited stuff and the gross out stuff that most of season 6 gave us. The music they were playing was awesome, Plankton's plan to get the formula was clever, and overall, just fun from beginning to end. 10/10
This episode was pretty good. In my opinion it's kinda underrated. I liked the idea of starting a band (nice Beatles reference). It was a Plankton steals the formula episode but it was nice. I loved the interaction between Spongebob, Patrick and Squidward (there wasn't unnecessary Squid abuse). There were some funny jokes. 8/10