Sheepie's Thanksgiving Cake V.S Pie Special!

TopSheep

twitch chat is a gift from god
Joined
Nov 16, 2014
Messages
989
Likes
342
Location
In Maine and Poland (at the same time)
Tomorrow is Thanksgiving.
I couldn't put it more simply.
So, in honor of this wonderful holiday, I'm going to host a CAKE V.S. PIE bracket.
As Ooooooofy knows, I am the wizard and expert of both.
You can still argue with my placement of certain desserts (Mincemeat, Boston Cream Pie), and I might fix them.
But I won't move Cheesecake. Cheesecake is a Pie. And if it's not, It's CLOSER to being a pie than a cake.
So don't bother brushing your teeth today. All it will do is make all this sugar taste bad.
Let the games BEGIN!
(And, although I am a sheep, I can thankfully digest everything. Everything but Mincemeat.)

I'll post one cake match-up and one pie match-up during every post.


First up:

Birthday-Cake-6-2.png

(Birthday Cake)​
V.S.​
(Angel Food Cake)​
angel_food_cake_pan_single_large3.jpg
And​
exps6086_HB133235C07_19_4b.jpg
(Apple Pie)​
V.S.​
(Brown Sugar Pie)​
brwnsgrpie%20copy.jpg

Yay!
 

TopSheep

twitch chat is a gift from god
Joined
Nov 16, 2014
Messages
989
Likes
342
Location
In Maine and Poland (at the same time)
Excuse me.
I have made a mistake.
It is not Apple V.S. Brown Sugar, but Apple V.S. Mincemeat. Here's a pretty picture.

(Mincemeat Pie)​
Yay.


Wait.
It's Brown Sugar.

I'm a moron.
So, vote!
 

TopSheep

twitch chat is a gift from god
Joined
Nov 16, 2014
Messages
989
Likes
342
Location
In Maine and Poland (at the same time)
I guess that'll do.
Birthday and Apple win.
Now:
pineapple-upside-down-cake-cut.jpg



(Pineapple Upside Down Cake)​
V.S.​
(Red Velvet Cake)​
red-velvet-cake.bmp
And​
01_WMT_10801_BakingCntr_C_POV_370x270_BostonCreamPie_US_ENG_01.jpg
(Boston Cream Pie)​
V.S.​
(Banana Cream Pie)​
banana_lg.jpg

I vote Pineapple Upside Down and Boston Cream Pie.
 

TopSheep

twitch chat is a gift from god
Joined
Nov 16, 2014
Messages
989
Likes
342
Location
In Maine and Poland (at the same time)
Fine, then.
Velvet and Boston win.
Now for:

52549415697ab052e2005f41._w.500_s.fit_.jpg
(Funfetti Cake)​
V.S.​
(Ice Cream Cake)​
74390451-985a-4ae6-aa2b-0c2b8a7981fa.jpg
And​
Triple-Layer_Lemon_Meringue_Pie.jpg
(Lemon Meringue Pie)​
V.S.​
(Strawberry Rhubarb Pie)​
Fresh-Strawberry-Rhubarb-Pie-2109.jpg
Yum!

I guess that I vote Funfetti and Lemon.
 

TopSheep

twitch chat is a gift from god
Joined
Nov 16, 2014
Messages
989
Likes
342
Location
In Maine and Poland (at the same time)
Ice Cream Cake:2-1:Funfetti
Lemon Meringue Pie:2-1:Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Yummy.


We have our winners! (Above post)
Now for the SPECIAL EXTRAVAGANZA!

carrot-cake-6001__98984__22842_zoom.jpg
(Carrot Cake)​
V.S.​
(Wedding Cake)​
winter-wedding-cakes-elegantly-iced-02.jpg
And​
pumpkin-pie.jpg
(Pumpkin Pie)​
V.S.​
(S'Mores Pie)​
Tasty-Kitchen-Blog-Smores-Pie-00.jpg

2Yummy4Me


I vote Carrot and..Pumpkin!
 
Back
Top